Summa summae S. Thomae sive compendium theologiae

Charles René Billuart

Summa summae S. Thomae sive compendium theologiae

Charles René Billuart (1685–1757)

First published 1754

Charles René Billuart, O.P.'s Summa summae S. Thomae sive compendium theologiae (Liège, 1754) is his six-volume abridgment of the larger Summa S. Thomae hodiernis academiarum moribus accommodata (1746–1751). It condenses Aquinas's order and teaching into a reference manual while retaining the Dominican's characteristic distinctions, scholastic proofs, and historical material. The compendium belongs to the eighteenth-century consolidation of post-Tridentine Thomist education and helped carry Billuart's influential reading of Aquinas into later schools. Schola presents the Latin text with an English translation from its public-domain source.


Proemium I: De natura et dotibus theologiae

Tractatus I: De Deo et Ejus Attributis

Dissertatio I: De Dei existentia

Articulus I: Utrum Deum esse sit per se notum

Articulus II: Utrum sit Deus, et quibus rationibus demonstretur?

Articulus III: De Atheismo

Articulus IV: Utrum possit dari ignorantia invincibilis de existentia Dei?

Articulus V: An existant athei theoretici?

Dissertatio II: De natura seu quidditate Dei et Ejus attributis in communi

Articulus I: Quodnam sit constitutivum divinae naturae?

Articulus II: De attributis divinis in communi

Dissertatio III: De attributis in particulari quae pertinent ad divinum esse

Articulus I: De simplicitate Dei

Articulus II: De perfectione Dei

Articulus III: De bonitate Dei

Tractatus I: De infinitate Dei

Tractatus II: De immensitate Dei

Articulus IV: De immutabilitate Dei

Articulus V: De aeternitate Dei

Articulus VI: An Deus sit unus?

Dissertatio IV: De visione Dei a nobis

Articulus I: Utrum Deus, ut est in se, possit videri oculo corporeo?

Articulus II: Utrum intellectus creatus supernaturaliter adiutus possit videre Deum ut in se est?

Articulus III: Utrum aliquis in hac vita viderit, possitve videre Deum ut est in se?

Articulus IV: Utrum essentia divina videatur aut videri possit per aliquam similitudinem seu speciem?

Dissertatio V: De scientia Dei

Articulus I: Utrum in Deo sit scientia proprie dicta, eaque sit attributum?

Articulus II: De obiecto et divisione scientiae Dei

Articulus III: An et quae scientia in Deo sit causa rerum?

Articulus IV: In quo medio Deus cognoscat alia a se?

Dissertatio VI: De praescientia futurorum

Articulus I: Quid et quotuplex sit futurum?

Articulus II: Utrum Deus certo et infallibiliter cognoscat omnia futura absoluta, contingentia et libera?

Articulus III: Quomodo futura sint praesentia in aeternitate?

Articulus IV: In quo medio Deus cognoscat futura absoluta, contingentia et libera?

Articulus V: De scientia futurorum conditionatorum

Articulus VI: De scientia media

Dissertatio VII: De voluntate Dei

Articulus I: De voluntate Dei secundum se, et eius obiecto

Articulus II: De libertate Dei

Articulus III: Quotuplex sit voluntas in Deo, et an semper impleatur?

Articulus IV: De voluntate Dei circa salutem omnium

Articulus V: Utrum Christus sit mortuus pro omnibus omnino hominibus?

Articulus VI: Utrum Deus omnibus provideat auxilia sufficientia ad salutem?

Dissertatio VIII: De praedefinitionibus seu decretis divinis circa actus nostros liberos

Articulus I: Unde repetenda sit infallibilis efficacia divinorum decretorum circa actus nostros liberos?

Articulus II: Solvuntur obiectiones

Dissertatio IX: De providentia, praedestinatione et reprobatione

Articulus I: De providentia

Articulus II: De praedestinatione

Articulus III: Utrum praedestinatio sit ex praevisis meritis, an mere gratuita

Articulus IV: Solvuntur obiectiones contra utramque conclusionem

Articulus V: De reprobatione

Articulus VI: De motivo reprobationis

Tractatus II: Tractatus de SS. Trinitatis Mysterio

Dissertatio I: De Veritate Mysterii SS. Trinitatis

Articulus I

Caput I: § I: Asseritur veritatis mysterii SS. Trinitatis

Caput II: § II Objectiones a ratione contra integrum mysterium

Articulus II: Utrum sanctissimae Trinitatis mysterium possit lumine naturali cognosci?

Dissertatio II: De processionibus divinarum personarum

Articulus I: Utrum in divinis sint processiones?

Articulus II: Unde processio Verbi habeat quod sit generatio, et non processio Spiritus Sancti?

Dissertatio III: De relationibus divinis

Articulus I: An sint et quot sint in Deo relationes reales?

Articulus II: Utrum relationes divinae habeant existentias relativas realiter inter se et virtualiter ab existentia essentiae distinctas?

Articulus III: Utrum relationes divinae, praeter perfectionem absolutam essentiae, afferant aliam relativam?

Dissertatio IV: De Personis Divinis

Articulus I: Utrum personae divinae constituantur relationibus?

Articulus II: Utrum in Deo secundum se considerato et personis praeintellecto sit aliqua subsistentia absoluta, et praeter illam sint insuper tres subsistentiae relativae

Articulus III: Utrum Spiritus sanctus procedat a Filio?

Articulus IV: De missione divinarum personarum

Tractatus III: Tractatus de Deo Creatore

Dissertatio I: De processione creaturarum a Deo

Articulus I: Utrum omne ens sit effective a Deo?

Articulus II: Utrum Deus sit causa exemplaris et finalis omnium rerum?

Articulus III: De modo emanationis rerum a Deo, qui dicitur creatio

Articulus IV: Utrum solius Dei sit creare

Articulus V: Utrum plures mundi sint possibiles, et mundus existens sit perfectus?

Articulus VI: Utrum creaturae indigeant ut a Deo conserventur?

Dissertatio II: De angelis

Articulus I: De existentia et quidditate angelorum

Articulus II: De loco et motu locali angelorum

Articulus III: De pertinentibus ad intellectum et voluntatem angelorum

Articulus IV: De gratia et gloria angelorum

Articulus V: De culpa angelorum

Articulus VI: De poena daemonum

Articulus VII: De locutione et illuminatione angelorum

Articulus VIII: De custodia bonorum angelorum et impugnatione malorum

St. Thomas, qq. 113 and 114.

You will ask 1° whether men are guarded by angels.

I answer affirmatively. This is of faith, expressed in many places of Scripture. Psal. XC, 11: He hath given his angels charge over thee, to keep thee in all thy ways. Genes., XXXII, 23 and XLVIII, 16; Matth., XVIII, 10; Luc., II, 9; Act., XII, 7, and elsewhere.

It is urged by reason. Man, established in the state of this life, is as it were on a certain road by which he must journey toward his homeland; on which road many dangers threaten man, both from within and from without. Therefore, just as guards are given to men walking along an unsafe road, so too to each man, as long as he is a wayfarer, a guardian angel is assigned. But when he has already reached the end of the road, then he will not have a guardian angel, but will have in the kingdom an angel reigning together with him, or in hell a demon punishing him.

You will ask 2° whether many men are guarded by one angel, or individual men by individual angels.

I answer that individual men are guarded by individual angels from birth.

The first part is gathered from Act., XII, 15. When the maidservant reported that Peter was standing at the door, the faithful, not believing it to be Peter, said: It is his angel. Whence Jerome, on chapter XVIII of Matth., says: « Great is the dignity of souls, that each one should have, from the very rise of its birth, an angel assigned to its guardianship. »

It is urged by reason. Divine providence, of which the guardianship of angels is a certain execution with regard to men, is concerned principally with those things which remain forever; but it is concerned with the things that pass away insofar as it itself orders them to

everlasting realities. But men are not incorruptible only as regards their common species, as other creatures are, but also as regards the proper forms of each individual, which are rational souls. Therefore the providence of God is related to individual men just as it is related to individual genera or species of corruptible things. — I subsume. But it is probable that different angels are set over different species of things. Therefore it is also reasonable that different angels should be assigned to different men for their guardianship.

The second part is against certain ancients, who said that a guardian angel is given only after Baptism. And 1° this is expressly asserted by Jerome, as cited. 2° It is proved by reason. The benefits which are provided by God to man insofar as he has a rational nature are shown to him from the very time that, by being born, he receives such a nature. But the guardianship of angels is such a benefit. Therefore.

Besides the Guardian Angels assigned from birth to individual private persons, the Fathers and theologians commonly acknowledge that special ones are moreover assigned to popes, kings, and other public persons and superiors, to direct them in those things which pertain to the government of the multitude committed to them. Likewise, a special one is also assigned to every nation, kingdom, province, city, diocese, religious order, community, college, confraternity, etc. It is also highly probable that an angel specially assigned is present to every priest celebrating, to assist him in the celebration of so great a mystery, and to offer his prayers and hosts to God. This is gathered from those words of the Canon of the Mass: « Command these things to be borne by the hands of thy holy angel to thy altar on high, etc. »

You will ask 3° what are the offices of the guardian angels toward us.

I answer 1° To illuminate the intellect, not by infusing species, but by adapting truths to our grasp, or by representing them under the likenesses of sensible things; and thus they instruct and teach, and suggest good thoughts; the will

too they arouse, by urging and exhorting to good, etc. They supply occasions of good, and remove occasions of evil. So it is found in Genes., XVI, 7 and XVIII, 2; Exod., XXIII, 20 seqq.; Iudith, XIII, 20; Tob., VI, 4, XI, 2 seqq., XII, 1 seqq.; Act., V, 19, and elsewhere.

2° — They offer our prayers and vows to God, Tob., III, 25 and XII, 12; Apocal., VIII, 3: not that God may thereby know them, but that they themselves may join their own prayers to our prayers.

3° — They avert external harm, help in dangers, in war, especially in death, put to flight diseases, pestilences, etc., Genes., XLVIII, 16; IV Reg., VI, 17 and XIX, 35; Tob., VI, 4 seqq., and elsewhere.

4° — They keep off and restrain demons, lest they do harm, or lest they do as much harm as they would wish, whether in temporal things or in spiritual things, Tob., VI, 16 seqq. and VIII, 3.

And although we continually receive so many and so great benefits from the guardian angels, we are so ungrateful that we scarcely recall the memory of such distinguished benefactors, whom it would be fitting to honor with special worship and reverence.

You will ask 4° whether guardian angels ever forsake their charges.

I answer that they never forsake them entirely, but sometimes in part and in a certain respect. The reason is that the guardianship of an angel, as we have said, is a certain execution of divine providence exercised generally with regard to men. But neither man, nor anything else, is entirely withdrawn from divine providence. Therefore. Sometimes, however, an angel does leave his charge in a certain respect, namely insofar as he does not prevent him either from being subjected to some tribulation, or from falling into sin, according to the order of the divine judgments. And in this sense Babylon and the house of Israel are said in the Scriptures to have been forsaken by the angels.

You will ask 5° whether angels grieve over our evils.

I answer negatively, because grief concerns those things which are against the will. But since angels have their will

conformed in all things to the divine will, nothing can happen against their will. Indeed, they do not will the sins and evils of men in themselves, but they do approve the will of God in permitting and avenging them.

[You will ask 6° from which order the guardian angels are. I answer that the guardian angels of private persons are from the lowest order, because to announce the least things pertains to the angels of the lowest order; and to attend to what concerns the salvation of one private person seems to be something minimal among the offices of angels. But the guardian angels of a multitude, or of those who preside over a multitude, are from other, higher orders, because the more universal an agent is, the higher it is. Thus, then, the guardianship of the human multitude pertains to the Principalities, or perhaps to the Archangels, who are called the princes of the angels. Further, according to St. Gregory, Hom. 34 in Evang., the Virtues have guardianship over all corporeal natures, the Powers have guardianship over the demons, and the Principalities or Dominations have guardianship over good spirits.]

You will ask 7° whether demons assail and tempt men.

I answer affirmatively, both because of envy, by which they strive to impede the progress of men, and because of pride, by which they usurp a likeness of divine power, assigning to themselves determinate ministers for the assault and ruin of men, just as God assigns determinate angels for the salvation of men. And this is clear from Genes., III, 1 seqq.; ad Ephes., VI, 11 seqq.; i ad Tim., II, 14; I Petr., V, 8 and 9, and from daily and unhappy experience.

You will ask 8° whether each person has his own evil angel for trial, just as each has a good one for guardianship.

I answer that many think so, following Origen, Hom. 12 in Luc.; Gregory of Nyssa, Tract. de vita Moysis; Cassian, Collat. 8, cap. 17, and St. Thomas, in II Sentent., dist. 11, a. 5, o.

Others deny it: 1° because this opinion has no foundation, neither in Scripture nor in tradition, but rather seems to have arisen from the superstition of the pagans, who assigned two genii to each man; 2° because there are many men incapable of exercise toward virtue, such as children and the insane; 3° because it is not likely that God would permit demons continually to lie in wait for men, who are already, from other causes, quite weak.

To those who are reported to have held the contrary, they answer that Origen abounds in many other errors; that the other Fathers do not agree with Gregory of Nyssa; that the works of Cassian were declared apocryphal by Pope Gelasius; and that St. Thomas, indeed, reports this opinion, but does not approve it.

Dissertatio III: De opere sex dierum

Articulus I: Utrum sex dies creationis sint reales?

Articulus II: Utrum cosmogonia Mosaica everti possit?

Dissertatio IV: De homine

Articulus I: Utrum primi parentes nostri immediate a Deo conditi fuerint?

Articulus II: An et qua ratione homo sit factus ad imaginem Dei?

Articulus III: Quomodo anima humana corpori uniatur?

Articulus IV: Utrum anima rationalis creetur, vel traducatur a parentibus?

Articulus V: Utrum anima rationalis creetur cum corpus humanum primo constituitur, id est in ipsa conceptione?

Articulus VI: Utrum primus homo creatus fuerit in statu gratiae sanctificantis?

Articulus VII: Quarum rerum cognitionem habuerit homo?

Articulus VIII: Utrum Adam innocens inordinatis concupiscentiae motibus fuerit obnoxius?

Articulus IX: Utrum corpus Adae vere fuerit de limo terrae?

Articulus X: Utrum homo in statu innocentiae fuerit immortalis?

Articulus XI: Utrum in statu innocentiae fuisset generatio ad multiplicationem hominum?

Articulus XII: Utrum in statu innocentiae homines nati fuissent iusti?

Articulus XIII: Utrum in statu innocentiae homines nati fuissent perfecti in scientia?

Articulus XIV: Quodnam fuerit primum peccatum protoparentum nostrorum?

Articulus XV: Quaenam fuerit gravitas peccati primorum parentum?

Articulus XVI: Quae fuerint poenae peccati primorum parentum?

Articulus XVII: Utrum primi parentes poenitentiam egerint et salutem consecuti fuerint?

Tractatus IV: De ultimo fine

Dissertatio I: De ultimo fine in communi

Articulus I: Quid et quotuplex sit finis?

Articulus II: Utrum homo in omnibus suis actionibus agat propter finem, idque sit proprium creaturae rationali?

Articulus III: Utrum idem homo possit appetere simul duos fines ultimos totales et adaequatos?

Articulus IV: Utrum omnia quae homo vult deliberate velit propter ultimum finem?

Articulus V: An et quomodo homo deliberate agens teneatur omnia et singula sua opera referre in Deum?

Dissertatio II: De beatitudine

Articulus I: In quo consistat beatitudo obiectiva hominis?

Articulus II: In quo consistat essentialiter formalis beatitudo hominis?

Articulus III: Utrum animae iustorum corporibus solutae et plene purgatae statim consequantur suam beatitudinem?

Articulus IV: De proprietatibus beatitudinis

Articulus V: De dotibus beatorum

Articulus VI: De aureolis beatorum

↑ Top of work