Summa Theologiae Moralis, vol. I: De Principiis
Benedictus Henricus Merkelbach (1871–1942)
Summa Theologiae Moralis ad mentem D. Thomae et ad normam iuris novi
First published 1935
Volume I (De principiis) of Benedictus Henricus Merkelbach's Summa theologiae moralis sets out the foundations of Catholic moral theology within a Thomistic framework. It treats human acts, conscience, law, sin, and merit in relation to the canon law of its period. The present edition follows the Paris text published by Desclée de Brouwer in 1935 and includes the Latin text with an English translation. It comprises the first volume of the three-volume Summa.
Prologus
Introductio I: Theologia Moralis Generalis: Introductio
Tractatus I: Tractatus de ultimo actu humanorum fine seu de beatitudine
Introductio
Quaestio I: DE FINE ULTIMO IN COMMUNI
Quaestio II: DE BEATITUDINE OBIECTIVA
Quaestio III: DE BEATITUDINE FORMALI
Quaestio IV: DE QUALITATIBUS BEATITUDINIS
Quaestio V: DE MODO OBTINENDI BEATITUDINEM
Tractatus II: De actibus humanis in se
Introductio
Pars I: De actibus humanis secundum esse materiale et psychologicum
§ I: De conditione actuum humanorum
Caput I: De elemento subiectivo actus humani
Quaestio I: De voluntario
Articulus I: De voluntario in se
Articulus II: De voluntario tum positivo et directo, tum negativo et indirecto
Articulus III: De voluntario in se et in causa
Quaestio II: De impedimentis voluntarii seu de involuntario
Articulus I: De violentia
Articulus II: De metu
Articulus III: De concupiscentia
Articulus IV: De ignorantia
Quaestio III: De libero
Quaestio IV: De impedimentis liberi
Articulus I: De passionibus
Articulus II: De habitu et consuetudine
Articulus III: De impedimentis liberi remotioribus
Caput II: De elemento obiectivo actus humani
Quaestio I: De elemento essentiali seu obiecto
Quaestio II: De elemento accidentali seu de circumstantiis
§ II: De distinctione actuum humanorum
Quaestio I: De actibus elicitis
Quaestio II: De actibus imperatis
Pars II: De actibus humanis secundum esse morale
§ I: De moralitate actus humani in genere
Quaestio I: De essentia et speciebus moralitatis
Quaestio II: De fundamentis moralitatis
Articulus I: De intrinseca differentia boni inter et mali
Articulus II: De norma moralitatis
Articulus III: De fundamento obiectivo moralitatis
Articulus IV: De falsis systematibus circa fundamenta moralitatis
Articulus V: De facultate apprehensiva moralitatis
Quaestio III: De principiis seu fontibus moralitatis
Quaestio IV: De distinctione specifica inter actum bonum et malum
Quaestio V: De distinctione specifica inter varios actus bonos vel malos
Articulus I: De obiecto
Articulus II: De circumstantiis
Articulus III: De fine
§ II: De moralitate actuum humanorum in specie
Quaestio I: De bonitate et malitia actus interioris
Quaestio II: De bonitate et malitia actus exterioris
Quaestio III: De bonitate et malitia effectus externi
Quaestio IV: De bonitate et malitia passionum
Quaestio V: De bonitate et malitia circumstantiarum
Pars III: De actibus humanis secundum esse supernaturale et meritorium
Quaestio I: De merito praesertim supernaturali
Quaestio II: De conditionibus meriti supernaturalis
Tractatus III: De conscientia in generali
Introductio
Quaestio I: De conscientia morali secundum se in esse psychologico
Quaestio II: De conscientia prout est regula actuum moralium
Articulus I: De rectitudine conscientiae
Articulus II: De conscientiae certitudine
Quaestio III: De conscientia christiana prout est regula actuum supernaturalium
Tractatus IV: De legibus in genere
Introductio
§ I: De lege secundum esse psychologicum
Pars I: De lege in genere
Quaestio I: De ipsa lege in se
Articulus I: De essentia legis
Articulus II: De promulgatione legis
Quaestio II: De distinctione legum
Quaestio III: De effectibus legis
Articulus I: De vi directivâ seu obligatione legis
Articulus II: De vi coactivâ seu sanctione legis
Pars II: De lege aeterna quae est fundamentum omnis legis
Quaestio I: De essentia legis aeternae
Quaestio II: De potestate legis aeternae
Quaestio III: De mutabilitate legis aeternae
§ I: De legibus quae regunt actus morales
Pars III: De lege naturali
Quaestio I: De essentia legis naturalis
Quaestio II: De potestate legis naturalis
Articulus I: De vi directivâ seu obligatione legis naturalis
Articulus II: De vi coactivâ seu sanctione legis naturalis
Quaestio III: De mutabilitate legis naturalis
Quaestio IV: De Lege Humana in Se
Articulus I: De Auctore legis civilis
Articulus II: De Qualitate legis humanae
Articulus III: De Efformatione legis humanae
Articulus IV: De Divisione legis humanae
Quaestio V: De Potestate Legis Humanae
Articulus I: De Materia legis humanae
Articulus II: De Obligatione legis humanae
Articulus III: De Subditis legis civilis
Articulus IV: De Impletione et Interpretatione legis humanae
Quaestio VI: De Mutabilitate Legis Humanae
Caput I: De Lege Vetere
Quaestio I: De Lege Vetere Secundum Se
Quaestio II: De Potestate Legis Veteris
Quaestio III: De Mutabilitate Veteris Legis
Caput II: De Lege Nova
Quaestio I: De Essentia Legis Novae
Quaestio II: De Potestate Legis Novae
Quaestio III: De Lege Ecclesiastica Secundum Se
Articulus I: De Auctore legis ecclesiasticae
Articulus II: De Materia et Qualitate legis ecclesiasticae
Articulus III: De Efformatione legis ecclesiasticae
Articulus IV: De Divisione legis ecclesiasticae
Quaestio IV: De Potestate seu Obligatione Legis Ecclesiasticae
Articulus I: De Quantitate seu Gravitate Obligationis
Articulus II: De Qualitate et Extensione Obligationis legis praeceptivae
Articulus III: De Qualitate et Extensione Obligationis legis poenalis
Articulus IV: De Qualitate et Extensione Obligationis legis irritantis
Articulus V: De Subditis legis ecclesiasticae
Articulus VI: De Impletione legis ecclesiasticae
Articulus VII: De Interpretatione legis ecclesiasticae
Quaestio V: De Mutabilitate Legis Ecclesiasticae
Articulus I: De Ignorantia
Articulus II: De Impotentia
Articulus III: De Dispensatione
Articulus IV: De privilegio
Articulus V: De cessatione finis
Articulus VI: De abrogatione et derogatione
Articulus VII: De consuetudine
Tractatus V: De peccatis in genere
Introductio I: De Peccatis in Genere
Quaestio I: De essentia peccati
Articulus I: De notione et conditionibus peccati
Articulus II: De peccato omissionis negative voluntario
Articulus III: De peccato commissionis externo, indirecte aut in causa voluntario
Articulus IV: De elementis constitutivis peccati
Articulus V: De definitione peccati
Quaestio II: De distinctione peccatorum
Articulus I: De distinctione specifica
Articulus II: De distinctione numerica
Quaestio III: De comparatione et gravitate peccatorum
Quaestio IV: De subiecto peccati
Articulus I: De motibus seu peccatis sensualitatis
Articulus II: De consensu in delectationem seu de delectatione morosa
Articulus III: De consensu in actum seu de desiderio et gaudio
Pars I: De causis peccatorum
Quaestio I: De causis peccati interioribus
Articulus I: De ignorantia causa peccati ex parte rationis
Articulus II: De passione causa peccati ex parte appetitus sensitivi
Articulus III: De malitia causa peccati ex parte voluntatis
Quaestio II: De causis peccatorum exterioribus
Articulus I: De deo permittente
Articulus II: De diabolo tentante
Articulus III: De homine cooperante
Quaestio III: De peccato quod est causa alterius peccati
Articulus I: De modo quo unum peccatum alterum causat
Articulus II: De superbia et inani gloria
Articulus III: De avaritia
Articulus IV: De luxuria et gula
Articulus V: De invidia et ira
Articulus VI: De acedia
Pars II: De effectibus peccatorum
Quaestio I: De diminutione boni naturae
Quaestio II: De reatu culpae seu macula peccati
Quaestio III: De reatu poenae
Quaestio IV: De peccato mortali et veniali
Articulus I: De differentia inter peccatum mortale et veniale
Articulus II: De gravitate peccati mortalis
Articulus III: De conditionibus ad peccatum mortale requisitis
Articulus IV: De divisione peccati mortalis et venialis
Articulus V: De conversione peccati mortalis et venialis
Articulus VI: De peccato veniali secundum se
Tractatus VI: De habitibus et virtutibus in genere
Introductio I: De Habitibus et Virtutibus in Genere
Pars I: De habitibus in genere secundum esse psychologicum
Quaestio I: De essentia habitus
Quaestio II: De subiecto habitus
Quaestio III: De causa habituum
Quaestio IV: De distinctione habituum
Pars II: De habitibus secundum esse morale seu de virtutibus acquisitis
Quaestio I: De essentia virtutis
Quaestio II: De subiecto virtutis
Quaestio III: De distinctione virtutum
Articulus I: De virtutibus intellectualibus
Articulus II: De virtutibus moralibus
Articulus III: De virtutibus cardinalibus
Quaestio IV: De proprietatibus virtutum
Articulus I: De medio virtutis
Articulus II: De connexione virtutum
Articulus III: De aequalitate virtutum
Articulus IV: De duratione virtutum
Pars III: De habitibus secundum esse supernaturale seu de virtutibus infusis
Quaestio I: De existentia et essentia infusorum habituum ac virtutum
Quaestio II: De distinctione infusorum habituum et virtutum
Articulus I: De virtutibus theologicis
Articulus II: De virtutibus moralibus
Articulus III: De donis spiritus sancti
Quaestio III: De causa infusorum habituum et virtutum
Quaestio IV: De proprietatibus infusorum habituum et virtutum
Articulus I: De medio virtutum infusarum
Articulus II: De connexione habituum infusorum
Articulus III: De aequalitate habituum infusorum
Articulus IV: De duratione habituum infusorum
Tractatus VII: De fide divina
Introductio
Quaestio I: De Obiecto Formali Fidei
Quaestio II: De Obiecto Materiali Fidei
Articulus I: De obiecto materiali in se
Articulus II: De conditionibus ad obiectum materiale requisitis
Articulus III: De evolutione obiecti materialis
Articulus IV: De ecclesia proponente obiectum fidei
Pars I: De Actu Fidei
Caput I: De Actu Fidei Interiore
Quaestio I: De Essentia Actus Fidei
Quaestio II: De Analysi Actus Fidei
Articulus I: De ipso actu fidei
Articulus II: De ipso credulitatis affectu
Articulus III: De iudicio credibilitatis seu de praeambulis fidei
Quaestio III: De Necessitate Fidei
Caput II: De Actu Fidei Exteriore seu de Eius Confessione
Pars II: De Habitu Fidei
Quaestio I: De Ipsa Fide
Articulus I: De fide in ordine ad subiectum spectata
Articulus II: De fide spectata relative ad virtutes supernaturales
Articulus III: De fide spectata relative ad habitus intellectuales
Quaestio II: De habentibus fidem
Quaestio III: De causa et effectibus fidei
S. Th. II-II, q. 6 and 7 ; De Verit., q. 8 and q. 18, a. 3.
726. God is the cause of faith : a) because He externally proposes both the things to be believed which we cannot know without divine revelation, and the manifest signs by which we know that this revelation is divine. But b) this is not enough, for many knowing these things do not believe ; hence an interior cause is also required which moves man interiorly to assent to those things which are of faith : but not only the free will alone, which is insufficient for a supernatural act ; therefore God also interiorly through grace (habitual or actual alone) moves us to assent to revealed truths. « Since man, by assenting to those things which are of faith, is elevated above his nature, this must be in him from a higher principle moving him interiorly, which is God. And therefore faith, as to the assent which is the principal act of faith, is from God moving interiorly through grace » (q. 6, a. 1). Faith, therefore, since it is by grace, is of itself infused.
727. Faith is supernatural, not only objectively because it has as its object the very truth of God revealing supernatural things ; but also subjectively because it is produced by a supernatural principle, the grace of God, not only medicinal or healing but also elevating. For it is impossible that by the powers of nature we attain any object which is in itself supernatural as such1] ; since faith, namely, is the beginning of salvation and the root of justification, it is the means by which we tend to an end in itself supernatural, but the means must be proportioned to the end. So the Council of Orange II defined, can. 5, 6, 7 ; and Trent, sess. 6, c. 6, can. 3 ; and Vat., sess. 3, c. 3, can. 5 against Hermes. — Cf. John VI, 44, 45, 64 ; Eph. II, 5, 8 ; 1 Cor. III, 7 ; 2 Cor. III, 5 ; Phil. I, 29.
Moreover, not only the act of faith itself, but also the very affection of credulity or motion of the will, as being the beginning of faith, is elicited by the powers of grace, as the Council of Orange II defined, can. 5 and 7, against the Semipelagians. For to tend toward a supernatural object, namely toward the act of faith, requires the powers of grace.
The judgment of credibility itself can perhaps be made by the powers of nature, because it has as its object the reasonableness of faith ; but when that judgment is immediately and ultimately practical (here and now it is to be believed by me, here and now you believe), so that it is made in order to supernatural faith and is the cause that we wish to believe and do believe, or that the will of believing follows it, then it deals with the supernatural object as such, namely the act of faith to be exercised, and pertains to the beginning of faith, and therefore cannot be made except by the powers of grace, as is certainly gathered from the same Council (can. 5) and from the Council of Milevis (can. 4). Cf. S. Augustine, l. 2, c. 2, ep. Pel., c. 8.
The act of faith and the judgment of credibility are elicited by the habit of theological faith in him who possesses it2] ; otherwise it is done only by the powers of actual grace. The pious affection of credulity itself, according to S. Thomas, is elicited by charity in the just man ; but in the sinner it is done only by the help of actual grace.
728. Observations. — 1° The powers of grace which are granted to our intellect, whether under the form of a habit or under the form of actual grace, so that it can believe, are called by the holy Fathers and theologians the light of faith : for just as by the light of reason we can know natural things, so by these powers, which elevate our intellect, we can supernaturally know supernatural things.
2° Faith elevates us to the supernatural and divine order ; hence the act of faith is supernatural not only in mode but in itself and as to substance : for it is divine, because as material and formal object it has God in Himself, such as can naturally be known only by Himself. Hence we believe the same truths which we shall see in heaven as mysteries, and indeed for the same motive : the first truth revealing them. The only difference is on the part of the condition of the object, which in heaven is clear, here remains obscure. Hence, as the beatific vision is an act of divine life, so also is faith.
3° The habit of faith not only causes the act of faith itself, but, as in other habits, its causality extends itself to other principal subordinate acts (I-II, q. 54, a. 4), whether they are preparatory acts of the principal act, or conservative of it. Hence, by the habit of faith are also produced both the acts pertaining to the previous judgment of credibility as was said in the preceding n°3]., and the acts by which (on account of the authority of the Church) are admitted truths not indeed in themselves revealed but connected with these, which are defined by the Church for the safe preservation of faith, or at least are proposed with authority.
4° From what has been said the various properties of faith are already known : on the part of the material object, infallibility and obscurity ; on the part of the will, freedom ; on the part of the judgment of credibility : reasonableness (and rational credibility of the object) ; on the part of the intellect adhering to the formal object, the highest certitude ; on the part of the external cause, God moving through grace : supernaturality ; on the part, finally, of the subject of faith there belongs irrevocability, as will be said below, n. 736, 3°.
729. Effects of faith. — Faith has as effects : 1° fear : inasmuch as by unformed faith we apprehend evils to be inflicted by divine judgment, it is the cause of servile fear, by which one fears to be punished by God ; inasmuch as by formed faith we esteem God as the Supreme Good, from which to be separated is the worst, and to be unwilling to be equal to which is evil, it is the cause of filial fear, by which one is subject to God and fears to be separated from God ; — 2° it has as effect the purification of the heart : for that is said to be impure which is mixed with baser things ; and that is purified which is mixed with nobler things. From which it is clear that a man becomes impure if he subjects himself with love to temporal things which are baser than himself ; but by faith he tends to things superior to himself, namely supernatural and divine things, and therefore faith is the principle of purification of the heart : unformed faith indeed purifies from error, which arises from the intellect's inordinate adherence to lower things ; formed faith also from the impurity of affection. Hence Acts XV, 9 : Faith purifying their hearts.