Summa Theologiae Moralis, vol. I: De Principiis
Benedictus Henricus Merkelbach (1871–1942)
Summa Theologiae Moralis ad mentem D. Thomae et ad normam iuris novi
First published 1935
Volume I (De principiis) of Benedictus Henricus Merkelbach's Summa theologiae moralis sets out the foundations of Catholic moral theology within a Thomistic framework. It treats human acts, conscience, law, sin, and merit in relation to the canon law of its period. The present edition follows the Paris text published by Desclée de Brouwer in 1935 and includes the Latin text with an English translation. It comprises the first volume of the three-volume Summa.
Prologus
Introductio I: Theologia Moralis Generalis: Introductio
Tractatus I: Tractatus de ultimo actu humanorum fine seu de beatitudine
Introductio
Quaestio I: DE FINE ULTIMO IN COMMUNI
Quaestio II: DE BEATITUDINE OBIECTIVA
Quaestio III: DE BEATITUDINE FORMALI
Quaestio IV: DE QUALITATIBUS BEATITUDINIS
Quaestio V: DE MODO OBTINENDI BEATITUDINEM
Tractatus II: De actibus humanis in se
Introductio
Pars I: De actibus humanis secundum esse materiale et psychologicum
§ I: De conditione actuum humanorum
Caput I: De elemento subiectivo actus humani
Quaestio I: De voluntario
Articulus I: De voluntario in se
Articulus II: De voluntario tum positivo et directo, tum negativo et indirecto
Articulus III: De voluntario in se et in causa
Quaestio II: De impedimentis voluntarii seu de involuntario
Articulus I: De violentia
Articulus II: De metu
Articulus III: De concupiscentia
Articulus IV: De ignorantia
Quaestio III: De libero
Quaestio IV: De impedimentis liberi
Articulus I: De passionibus
Articulus II: De habitu et consuetudine
Articulus III: De impedimentis liberi remotioribus
Caput II: De elemento obiectivo actus humani
Quaestio I: De elemento essentiali seu obiecto
Quaestio II: De elemento accidentali seu de circumstantiis
§ II: De distinctione actuum humanorum
Quaestio I: De actibus elicitis
Quaestio II: De actibus imperatis
Pars II: De actibus humanis secundum esse morale
§ I: De moralitate actus humani in genere
Quaestio I: De essentia et speciebus moralitatis
Quaestio II: De fundamentis moralitatis
Articulus I: De intrinseca differentia boni inter et mali
Articulus II: De norma moralitatis
Articulus III: De fundamento obiectivo moralitatis
Articulus IV: De falsis systematibus circa fundamenta moralitatis
Articulus V: De facultate apprehensiva moralitatis
Quaestio III: De principiis seu fontibus moralitatis
Quaestio IV: De distinctione specifica inter actum bonum et malum
Quaestio V: De distinctione specifica inter varios actus bonos vel malos
Articulus I: De obiecto
Articulus II: De circumstantiis
Articulus III: De fine
§ II: De moralitate actuum humanorum in specie
Quaestio I: De bonitate et malitia actus interioris
Quaestio II: De bonitate et malitia actus exterioris
Quaestio III: De bonitate et malitia effectus externi
Quaestio IV: De bonitate et malitia passionum
Quaestio V: De bonitate et malitia circumstantiarum
Pars III: De actibus humanis secundum esse supernaturale et meritorium
Quaestio I: De merito praesertim supernaturali
Quaestio II: De conditionibus meriti supernaturalis
Tractatus III: De conscientia in generali
Introductio
Quaestio I: De conscientia morali secundum se in esse psychologico
Quaestio II: De conscientia prout est regula actuum moralium
Articulus I: De rectitudine conscientiae
Articulus II: De conscientiae certitudine
Quaestio III: De conscientia christiana prout est regula actuum supernaturalium
Tractatus IV: De legibus in genere
Introductio
§ I: De lege secundum esse psychologicum
Pars I: De lege in genere
Quaestio I: De ipsa lege in se
Articulus I: De essentia legis
Articulus II: De promulgatione legis
Quaestio II: De distinctione legum
Quaestio III: De effectibus legis
Articulus I: De vi directivâ seu obligatione legis
Articulus II: De vi coactivâ seu sanctione legis
Pars II: De lege aeterna quae est fundamentum omnis legis
Quaestio I: De essentia legis aeternae
Quaestio II: De potestate legis aeternae
Quaestio III: De mutabilitate legis aeternae
§ I: De legibus quae regunt actus morales
Pars III: De lege naturali
Quaestio I: De essentia legis naturalis
Quaestio II: De potestate legis naturalis
Articulus I: De vi directivâ seu obligatione legis naturalis
Articulus II: De vi coactivâ seu sanctione legis naturalis
Quaestio III: De mutabilitate legis naturalis
Quaestio IV: De Lege Humana in Se
Articulus I: De Auctore legis civilis
Articulus II: De Qualitate legis humanae
Articulus III: De Efformatione legis humanae
Articulus IV: De Divisione legis humanae
Quaestio V: De Potestate Legis Humanae
Articulus I: De Materia legis humanae
Articulus II: De Obligatione legis humanae
Articulus III: De Subditis legis civilis
Articulus IV: De Impletione et Interpretatione legis humanae
Quaestio VI: De Mutabilitate Legis Humanae
Caput I: De Lege Vetere
Quaestio I: De Lege Vetere Secundum Se
Quaestio II: De Potestate Legis Veteris
Quaestio III: De Mutabilitate Veteris Legis
Caput II: De Lege Nova
Quaestio I: De Essentia Legis Novae
Quaestio II: De Potestate Legis Novae
Quaestio III: De Lege Ecclesiastica Secundum Se
Articulus I: De Auctore legis ecclesiasticae
Articulus II: De Materia et Qualitate legis ecclesiasticae
Articulus III: De Efformatione legis ecclesiasticae
Articulus IV: De Divisione legis ecclesiasticae
Quaestio IV: De Potestate seu Obligatione Legis Ecclesiasticae
Articulus I: De Quantitate seu Gravitate Obligationis
Articulus II: De Qualitate et Extensione Obligationis legis praeceptivae
Articulus III: De Qualitate et Extensione Obligationis legis poenalis
Articulus IV: De Qualitate et Extensione Obligationis legis irritantis
Articulus V: De Subditis legis ecclesiasticae
Articulus VI: De Impletione legis ecclesiasticae
Articulus VII: De Interpretatione legis ecclesiasticae
Quaestio V: De Mutabilitate Legis Ecclesiasticae
Articulus I: De Ignorantia
Articulus II: De Impotentia
Articulus III: De Dispensatione
Articulus IV: De privilegio
Articulus V: De cessatione finis
Articulus VI: De abrogatione et derogatione
Articulus VII: De consuetudine
Tractatus V: De peccatis in genere
Introductio I: De Peccatis in Genere
Quaestio I: De essentia peccati
Articulus I: De notione et conditionibus peccati
Articulus II: De peccato omissionis negative voluntario
Articulus III: De peccato commissionis externo, indirecte aut in causa voluntario
Articulus IV: De elementis constitutivis peccati
Articulus V: De definitione peccati
Quaestio II: De distinctione peccatorum
Articulus I: De distinctione specifica
Articulus II: De distinctione numerica
Quaestio III: De comparatione et gravitate peccatorum
Quaestio IV: De subiecto peccati
Articulus I: De motibus seu peccatis sensualitatis
Articulus II: De consensu in delectationem seu de delectatione morosa
Articulus III: De consensu in actum seu de desiderio et gaudio
Pars I: De causis peccatorum
Quaestio I: De causis peccati interioribus
Articulus I: De ignorantia causa peccati ex parte rationis
Articulus II: De passione causa peccati ex parte appetitus sensitivi
Articulus III: De malitia causa peccati ex parte voluntatis
Quaestio II: De causis peccatorum exterioribus
Articulus I: De deo permittente
Articulus II: De diabolo tentante
Articulus III: De homine cooperante
Quaestio III: De peccato quod est causa alterius peccati
Articulus I: De modo quo unum peccatum alterum causat
Articulus II: De superbia et inani gloria
Articulus III: De avaritia
Articulus IV: De luxuria et gula
Articulus V: De invidia et ira
Articulus VI: De acedia
Pars II: De effectibus peccatorum
Quaestio I: De diminutione boni naturae
Quaestio II: De reatu culpae seu macula peccati
Quaestio III: De reatu poenae
Quaestio IV: De peccato mortali et veniali
Articulus I: De differentia inter peccatum mortale et veniale
Articulus II: De gravitate peccati mortalis
Articulus III: De conditionibus ad peccatum mortale requisitis
Articulus IV: De divisione peccati mortalis et venialis
Articulus V: De conversione peccati mortalis et venialis
Articulus VI: De peccato veniali secundum se
Tractatus VI: De habitibus et virtutibus in genere
Introductio I: De Habitibus et Virtutibus in Genere
Pars I: De habitibus in genere secundum esse psychologicum
Quaestio I: De essentia habitus
Quaestio II: De subiecto habitus
Quaestio III: De causa habituum
Quaestio IV: De distinctione habituum
Pars II: De habitibus secundum esse morale seu de virtutibus acquisitis
Quaestio I: De essentia virtutis
Quaestio II: De subiecto virtutis
Quaestio III: De distinctione virtutum
Articulus I: De virtutibus intellectualibus
Articulus II: De virtutibus moralibus
Articulus III: De virtutibus cardinalibus
Quaestio IV: De proprietatibus virtutum
Articulus I: De medio virtutis
Articulus II: De connexione virtutum
Articulus III: De aequalitate virtutum
Articulus IV: De duratione virtutum
Pars III: De habitibus secundum esse supernaturale seu de virtutibus infusis
Quaestio I: De existentia et essentia infusorum habituum ac virtutum
Quaestio II: De distinctione infusorum habituum et virtutum
Articulus I: De virtutibus theologicis
Articulus II: De virtutibus moralibus
Articulus III: De donis spiritus sancti
Quaestio III: De causa infusorum habituum et virtutum
Quaestio IV: De proprietatibus infusorum habituum et virtutum
Articulus I: De medio virtutum infusarum
Articulus II: De connexione habituum infusorum
Articulus III: De aequalitate habituum infusorum
Articulus IV: De duratione habituum infusorum
Tractatus VII: De fide divina
Introductio
Quaestio I: De Obiecto Formali Fidei
Quaestio II: De Obiecto Materiali Fidei
Articulus I: De obiecto materiali in se
Articulus II: De conditionibus ad obiectum materiale requisitis
Articulus III: De evolutione obiecti materialis
Articulus IV: De ecclesia proponente obiectum fidei
Pars I: De Actu Fidei
Caput I: De Actu Fidei Interiore
Quaestio I: De Essentia Actus Fidei
Quaestio II: De Analysi Actus Fidei
Articulus I: De ipso actu fidei
Articulus II: De ipso credulitatis affectu
Articulus III: De iudicio credibilitatis seu de praeambulis fidei
Quaestio III: De Necessitate Fidei
Caput II: De Actu Fidei Exteriore seu de Eius Confessione
Pars II: De Habitu Fidei
Quaestio I: De Ipsa Fide
Articulus I: De fide in ordine ad subiectum spectata
Articulus II: De fide spectata relative ad virtutes supernaturales
Articulus III: De fide spectata relative ad habitus intellectuales
Quaestio II: De habentibus fidem
Quaestio III: De causa et effectibus fidei
Quaestio IV: De donis fidei correspondentibus
Pars III: De vitiis et peccatis fidei oppositis
Quaestio I: De peccatis directe oppositis fidei
Articulus I: De infidelitate
Articulus II: De haeresi et apostasia
Quaestio II: De peccatis indirecte oppositis fidei
Articulus I: De communicatione cum infidelibus et haereticis
Articulus II: De cooperatione ad infidelitatem et haeresim
Articulus III: De lectione et evulgatione scriptorum prohibitorum
Articulus IV: De admissione vel professione doctrinae quae pro fide est periculosa
Quaestio III: De blasphemia quae opponitur confessioni fidei
Pars IV: De praecepto fidei
Quaestio I: Quaestio unica
Tractatus VIII: De spe divina
Introductio
Pars I: De obiecto et actu spei
Quaestio I: De obiecto formali spei
Quaestio II: De obiecto materiali spei
Quaestio III: De necessitate spei
Pars II: De habitu et subiecto spei
Quaestio I: De spe ut est virtus
Quaestio II: De subiecto spei
Quaestio III: De timore dei
Pars III: De peccatis spei oppositis
Quaestio I: De desperatione
Quaestio II: De praesumptione
Pars IV: De praecepto spei
Quaestio I: De Praecepto Spei
Tractatus IX: De divina charitate
Introductio I: De Divina Charitate
Pars I: De ipsa charitate
Quaestio I: De essentia charitatis
Quaestio II: De excellentia charitatis
Articulus I: De excellentia charitatis in se
Articulus II: De excellentia charitatis relative ad alias virtutes
Quaestio III: De charitate quoad subiectum spectata
Articulus I: De subiecto et generatione charitatis
Articulus II: De augmento charitatis
Articulus III: De diminutione et amissione charitatis
Pars II: De obiecto charitatis
Quaestio I: De obiecto formali
Quaestio II: De obiecto materiali charitatis
Articulus I: De diligendis ex charitate generatim
Articulus II: De diligendo deo
Articulus III: De diligendo seipso
Articulus IV: De peccatoribus diligendis
Articulus V: De inimicis diligendis
Quaestio III: De ordine charitatis
Articulus I: De ordine inter deum et nos
Articulus II: De ordine inter nos et proximum
Articulus III: De ordine inter varios proximos
Pars III: De actibus charitatis
Quaestio I: De actu proprio seu dilectione
Quaestio II: De effectibus internis charitatis
S. Th. II-II, q. 28, 29, 30, 45.
920. There are three internal effects of charity:
1st is joy which is caused by love, either a) on account of this that the good is in the loved and is preserved in him, and thus we rejoice in the immutable goodness of God (the joy of friendship completing the love of complacence), or b) on account of the presence of the loved, and thus we rejoice fully in God in heaven, or even on earth in his inhabitation in the soul (the joy of concupiscence fulfilling the desire of the lover).
The first joy cannot have any sadness mingled with it; — likewise the other joy in heaven, where it will be altogether full because nothing remains to be desired, indeed superfull because more is given than is desired; not however now on earth, where from itself there can also follow sadness for those things which are repugnant to the perfection of the participation of the divine good and which are contrary to the effects of charity in us or in our neighbor.
In a similar way we can rejoice in our own goods, and rejoice with our neighbor in his goods.
2nd is peace which includes two things: a) concord or union of our will with the will of others: this charity makes inasmuch as we love our neighbors as ourselves; from which it follows that a man wishes to fulfill the will of his neighbor as of himself, and so two wills tend to one; b) union of all our appetites: this charity makes inasmuch as we love God with our whole heart and refer all things to him; and so all our appetites tend to one.
3rd is mercy which is defined by S. Augustine, de Civ. Dei, l. 9: "a compassion in our heart for another's misery or sadness, by which we are compelled, if we can, to help". For since the lover regards his friend as himself, the evil of him he regards as his own, and therefore he is grieved by it as by his own, and wishes to relieve his misery, as his own.
Joy and peace are secondary acts of charity, naturally and necessarily following dilection; they have the same object and motive as dilection, whence they are not distinct habits. Mercy however is a special virtue because it has a special object, namely another's misery to be relieved by our help out of compassion, and a special appetite, namely sorrow for another's misery, to be moderated by reason; for misery consists in this that a man suffers what he does not wish, i.e. evil which is in some way involuntary for him, and so the sin of another also is an object of mercy, inasmuch as it has certain evils annexed which are against the will of the sinner, such as the obligation of punishment, infirmity, separation from God, etc.
921. Remark. — Mercy is the greatest of all virtues, if considered in itself, because to give to others and to relieve their defects is most of the superior, and therefore is proper to God, in whom it is not distinguished from gratuitous love or charity which it includes and extends to others. But if considered as regards the man having it, it is not the greatest because it is greater to be united to the superior God, which is done immediately by the theological virtues and mediately by certain others; but among all virtues which pertain to the neighbor it is the greatest, because to be suppliant to a defect inasmuch as such is of the better (q. 30, a. 4). Thus it is annexed not only to charity but also to justice, and pertains to liberality of which it is a species (III Sent., d. 33, q. 3, a. 4, qc. 4.).
922. The Gift of Wisdom corresponds to charity, as being among the gifts of the Holy Spirit the most perfect. Wisdom is taken: a) for the natural and acquired intellectual virtue by which a man promptly judges of all things through the highest causes known by reason; b) for the supernatural and infused gift by which a man through the highest supernatural cause, God, and the divine rules, can judge and order all things by connaturality. Which judgment a man obtains through the Holy Spirit (I Cor. II, 15 and 10), and therefore this wisdom is a gift of the Holy Spirit.
Wisdom resides in the intellect because its act is to judge; but it has its cause in the will, namely charity by which we are connatural to divine things, since it unites us to God: hence it is of wisdom to judge with savor, taste, suavity and delectation. Whence wisdom is not in sinners. Moreover it not only contemplates divine things but also by divine reasons judges of human things; hence it is speculative together with practical.
From the aforesaid its definition is clear: A habit divinely infused, by which the mind is rendered easily moved by the Holy Spirit to contemplate divine things, and to judge of them, and of human things according to divine reasons.
Just as charity according to the threefold state of men is divided into the charity of beginners, and of those progressing, and of the perfect, which is not a specific but a gradual distinction, conformably a threefold degree of wisdom exists.
"All having charity and sanctifying grace have the gift of wisdom at least according to this its first degree. But this degree of wisdom consists in two things. First in this that through it the intellect judges that one must rather adhere to divine things than to created and transitory things, saying that of the Psalmist: To me to adhere to God is good. Second, that through it one rightly disposes and rules one's human and external works according to divine laws, according to divine precepts or counsels...
The second degree of wisdom belongs to those progressing, consisting in this that for the sake of perceiving and experiencing spiritual and most pure suavity or delectation of wisdom, a man despises and forsakes all enticements of the flesh and delights of the world, and strives to fix his intellect with all his strength in the clear and savory speculation of divine things, endeavoring to ascend to the limpidity of angelic conversation...
The third degree of wisdom belongs to the perfect only, and consists in this, that no knowledge of any created thing is savory, delightful or pleasing to the intellect, except inasmuch as it contributes to the knowledge of divine things, and thus the mind itself is totally fixed in the contemplation of divine things; so that it can promptly, sincerely, subtly and sweetly contemplate them, with the passions so calmed, and the exterior man entirely reformed, ordered and subjected to the rule of reason at will, as much as the fragility of the present life admits or sustains..."1.
To the gift of wisdom is attributed the 7th beatitude: Blessed are the peacemakers for they shall be called sons of God: 1) as to merit, for the peace are those who make peace either in themselves or in others, which is done by bringing them back to the due order; but to order pertains to wisdom; therefore to be peaceable is fittingly attributed to wisdom; 2) as to reward, for they shall be sons of God by participating in the likeness of the only-begotten Son of God who is the very uncreated Wisdom begotten.
923. Remark. — Note the words of S. Thomas, q. 45, a. 5: "Some attain only so much of right judgment both in the contemplation of divine things and also in the ordering of human things according to divine rules, as is necessary for salvation; and this is wanting to many who are in a state of sanctifying grace without mortal sin... Others however perceive the gift of wisdom in a higher degree both as to the contemplation of divine things, inasmuch namely as they know certain higher mysteries and can manifest them to others; and also as to the direction of human things according to divine rules inasmuch as they can according to them order not only themselves but also others; and this degree of wisdom is not common to all having sanctifying grace, but rather pertains to the gratuitous graces which the Holy Spirit distributes as he wills according to that of I Cor. XII, 8: To others..."