De Consideratione

Bernard of Clairvaux

De Consideratione

Bernard of Clairvaux (1090–1153)

First published 1839

De Consideratione ad Eugenium (On Consideration, to Eugene) is Bernard of Clairvaux's last major treatise, composed between 1149 and 1152 and addressed to Pope Eugene III, a former monk of Clairvaux whom Bernard had personally formed before his elevation to the papacy. Written in five books, the work is at once a spiritual manual and a mirror for princes: Bernard urges the newly burdened pope not to let the ceaseless business of Rome — litigation, petitions, the "malicious occupations" of the Curia — extinguish the interior life of consideratio, the reflective self-examination that alone keeps action rightly ordered. The treatise moves outward in careful stages, following the fourfold scheme Bernard sets as its architecture: the pope's consideration of himself, of what lies beneath him (the clergy and people of Rome), of what surrounds him (the cardinals and household), and finally of what lies above him, culminating in Book V's ascent toward the contemplation of God, angelic hierarchy, and the divine nature itself. Alongside its mystical and pastoral concerns, the work is notable for its unsparing critique of curial corruption, its meditation on the proper limits of papal power (including the celebrated distinction between the "two swords"), and its warning — startling in an address to a reigning pope — that Eugene's worldly pomp descends "not from Peter, but from Constantine." Blending rhetorical intensity, biblical exegesis, and Cistercian spirituality, De Consideratione stands as one of the most influential texts of twelfth-century ecclesiology and remains a foundational witness to the monastic critique of ecclesiastical power.


Prologue

Liber Primus

Caput I: St. Bernard sympathizes with the Pope in his many cares

Caput II: The strength of evil custom

Caput III: The rulers of the Church ought not to be for ever hearing and deciding lawsuits

Caput IV: What service is worthy, what unworthy, of the servants of God

Caput V: The Pope should not be so absorbed in other men's affairs as to neglect himself

Caput VI: The administration of justice concerns temporal governors rather than bishops

Caput VII: Nothing more deserving of consideration than piety and things eternal

Caput VIII: The four primary virtues

Caput IX: The recent practice of the Pope to be gradually corrected, the old imitated

Caput X: The shameless trickery of advocates, judges, and procurators

Caput XI: Such iniquitous greed to be sternly rebuked

Liber Secundus

Caput I: St. Bernard apologizes for the failure of the Second Crusade

Caput II: Consideration distinguished from Contemplation

Caput III: Consideration fourfold—(1) The Pope himself, (2) things below him, (3) things around him, (4) things above him

Caput IV: The threefold Consideration leading to self-knowledge. Firstly, What the Pope is

Caput V: Secondly, Who the Pope is, and whence he comes

Caput VI: The zeal befitting ecclesiastical rulers

Caput VII: Who the Pope is—(continued)

Caput VIII: The dignity and power of the Pope

Caput IX: St. Bernard invites the Pope to consider what he is by nature

Caput X: What manner of man the Pope is

Caput XI: The necessity for self-examination

Caput XII: The spiritual effects of prosperity and adversity

Caput XIII: Idleness, trifling, and profitless conversation to be shunned

Caput XIV: The Pope warned against accepting the person of any

Liber Tertius

Caput I: The Pope should aim not at subjecting all men to himself, but at bringing them into the bosom of the Church

Caput II: The limits of appeals to the Apostolic See

Caput III: Church rulers are for the profit of their people

Caput IV: Ecclesiastical rank and dignity to be respected. The abuse of privileges and exemptions

Caput V: The Sovereign Pontiff should uphold the Apostolic decrees and ancient ordinances throughout the world

Liber Quartus

Caput I: The things 'around' the Pope

Caput II: The clergy and people of Rome. The care and watchfulness of shepherds in olden time

Caput III: The necessity of curtailing extravagance in dress, &c.

Caput IV: The Pope’s colleagues and coadjutors at the Lateran

Caput V: The Pope should refuse bribes. Martin and Gaufrid. The arrogance of the Pope's attendants

Caput VI: It is not becoming in the Pope to be absorbed in the management of his household to the neglect of weightier matters. He should have a steward

Caput VII: The ideal Pope

Liber Quintus

Caput I: The things ‘above’ us, namely, God and things Divine, to which we rise by means of the Creatures

Caput II: The Steps of Consideration

Caput III: Opinion, Faith, and Understanding

5. Enough about the way up, you say ; I have still to tell you whither you must ascend. You deceive yourself if you expect me to do that ; it transcends the power of speech. Do you think that I can utter what eye hath not seen, nor ear heard, and has not entered into the heart of man ? ‘ God ’, the apostle says, ‘ has revealed them to us by His Spirit.’ So then the things which are above are not taught by words, they are revealed by the Spirit. But what speech does not explain let Consideration seek, prayer desire, the life merit, purity attain. At all events, when I admonish you to consider the things which are above you, do not think that I am sending you to gaze at the sun, moon, and stars ; no, not the firmament itself, nor the waters which are above the heavens. For all these things, though locally ‘ above ’, are in point of value ‘ beneath ’ you, even in dignity of nature, as they are material existences. Your portion is the spirit, whereby you in vain look for anything above you which is not spirit. Moreover, God is a Spirit, and so are the holy angels, and they are above you. But God is a Spirit in virtue of His nature, the angels are your superiors through grace. The special excellence both of yourself and of angelic beings is reason ; but in God there is no peculiar excellence ; He is altogether excellent. He, and the blessed spirits who are with Him, must in three ways, as it were along their several paths, be by our Consideration sought after—the paths of opinion, faith, and understanding. Of these, understanding depends on reason, faith on authority, while opinion safeguards itself by probability only. Two of them attain to the certainty of truth, but faith possesses truth out of sight and implied, understanding has it naked and manifest; opinion, having no certainty, does not so much apprehend truth as seek it through probabilities.

6. The utmost caution must be exercised so as to avoid confusion, lest the uncertainties of opinion crystallize into articles of faith, or the foundation verities of faith become the questionable matter of opinion. And we should bear this in mind—that opinion venturing on assertion is rash; faith, if it hesitate, is weak; and understanding, if it try to break into the sealed mysteries of faith, is deemed a burglar, and a spy upon the secrets of the throne. Many have taken their own opinion for understanding, and have thus erred. And in truth opinion may be taken for understanding; understanding cannot be taken for opinion. How so? Surely because opinion may be deceived, understanding cannot be; if it could, it would not be understanding, but opinion. For true understanding has not only certain truth, but the knowledge of truth. We may thus define each of them. Faith is, by the exercise of the will, a sure foretaste of truth not yet manifested. Understanding is the sure and clear knowledge of some invisible thing. Opinion is the holding something provisionally true which you do not know to be false. So then, as I have said, faith is free from doubts; if it have doubts it is not faith, but opinion. How, then, does it differ from understanding? Inasmuch as, although there be no more uncertainty in it than there is in understanding, still it has a veil before its eyes, which is not the case with understanding. In short, if you understand a thing, further inquiry is needless; if further inquiry be necessary, you do not understand. But there is nothing we would rather know than what we already know by faith. When the veil shall have been utterly removed from the things of which we are now assured by faith, the cup of bliss will be full.

Caput IV: The Angels

Caput V: God is the Source of Angelic Gifts and Graces

Caput VI: The Eternal Self-existence of God

Caput VII: The Divine Trinity in Unity

Caput VIII: The plurality of Persons in the Godhead, and their several 'properties'. The unity and simplicity of the Essence

Caput IX: As in God there are three Persons and one Nature: so in Christ there are two Natures and one Person

Caput X: The Parable of the three Measures of Meal

Caput XI: The consideration of God continued

Caput XII: God the rewarder of the good, and the righteous judge of the wicked

Caput XIII: The mystical interpretation of the length and breadth, and height, and depth

Caput XIV: What it is to 'comprehend' God

↑ Top of work