Cratylus

Plato

Cratylus

Plato (428–347 BC)

Plato's Cratylus in the Greek text edited by John Burnet, with Harold North Fowler's English translation.


Section 383

Section 384

Section 385

Section 386

Section 387

Section 388

Section 389

Section 390

Section 391

Section 392

Section 393

Section 394

Section 395

Section 396

Section 397

Section 398

Section 399

Section 400

Section 401

Section 402

Section 403

Section 404

Section 405

Section 406

Section 407

Section 408

Section 409

Section 410

Section 411

Section 412

Section 413

Section 414

Section 415

Section 416

Section 417

Section 418

Section 419

Section 420

Section 421

Section 422

Section 423

Section 424

Section 425

Section 426

Section 427

Socrates. Therefore he imitates the nature of ἰέναι (go) and ἵεσθαι (hasten) by means of iota, just as he has imitated all such notions as ψυχρόν (cold, shivering), ζέον (seething), σείεσθαι (shake), and σεισμός (shock) by means of phi, psi, sigma, and zeta, because those letters are pronounced with much breath. Whenever he imitates that which resembles blowing, the giver of names always appears to use for the most part such letters. And again he appears to have thought that the compression and pressure of the tongue in the pronunciation of delta and tau was naturally fitted to imitate the notion of binding and rest. And perceiving that the tongue has a gliding movement most in the pronunciation of lambda, he made the words λεῖα (level), ὀλισθάναιν (glide) itself, λιπαρόν (sleek), κολλῶδες (glutinous), and the like to conform to it. Where the gliding of the tongue is stopped by the sound of gamma he reproduced the nature of γλισχρόν (glutinous), γλυκύ (sweet), and γλοιῶδες (gluey). And again, perceiving that nu is an internal sound, he made the words ἔνδον (inside) and ἐντός (within), assimilating the meanings to the letters, and alpha again he assigned to greatness, and eta to length, because the letters are large. He needed the sign Ο for the expression of γόγγυλον (round), and made it the chief element of the word. And in this way the lawgiver appears to apply the other letters, making by letters and syllables a name for each and every thing, and from these names he compounds all the rest by imitation. This, Hermogenes, appears to me to be the theory of the correctness of names, unless, indeed, Cratylus has some other view.

Hermogenes. Truly, Socrates, as I said in the beginning, Cratylus often troubles me a good deal; he declares that there is such a thing as correctness of names, but does not say clearly what it is; and so I cannot tell whether he speaks so obscurely about it on any given occasion intentionally or unintentionally. So now, Cratylus, tell me, in the presence of Socrates, do you like what Socrates says about names, or have you a better theory to propose? And if you have, tell us about it; then you will either learn from Socrates or instruct both him and me.

Cratylus. But, Hermogenes, do you think it is an easy matter to learn or teach any subject so quickly, especially so important an one as this, which appears to me to be one of the most important?

Section 428

Section 429

Section 430

Section 431

Section 432

Section 433

Section 434

Section 435

Section 436

Section 437

Section 438

Section 439

Section 440

↑ Top of work