Commentaria in Summam contra Gentiles, Liber IV
Francesco Silvestri (1474–1528)
Commentaria in Summam contra Gentiles
First published 1918
In Book IV of the Commentaria in Summam contra Gentiles, Francesco Silvestri of Ferrara (Ferrariensis) examines Aquinas's treatment of revealed mysteries: the Trinity, the Incarnation, the sacraments, and the resurrection. The commentary accompanies the Leonine text in volume XV (1930). The present digital edition includes the Latin text and an English translation.
Prooemium
Caput I: Quod sit generatio, paternitas et filiatio in divinis
Caput II: Quod filius Dei sit Deus
Caput III: Quid opinatus sit Photinus de filio Dei, et eius improbatio
Caput IV: Opinio Sabellii de filio Dei, et eius improbatio
Caput V: De opinione Arii circa filium Dei
Caput VI: Improbatio opinionis Arii de filio Dei
Caput VII: Solutio ad auctoritates quas Arius pro se inducebat
Caput VIII: Solutio ad auctoritates Photini et Sabellii
Caput IX: Rationes contra generationem et processionem divinam
Caput X: Quomodo accipienda sit generatio in divinis, et quae de filio Dei dicuntur in Scripturis
Caput XI: Quomodo filius Dei dicatur Dei sapientia
Caput XII: Quod non est nisi unus filius in divinis
Caput XIII: Solutio ad rationes supra inductas contra generationem divinam
Caput XIV: De spiritu sancto, quod sit in divinis
Caput XV: Rationes ex quibus aliqui spiritum sanctum existimaverunt esse creaturam
Caput XVI: Quod spiritus sanctus sit verus Deus
Caput XVII: Quod spiritus sanctus sit subsistens persona
Caput XVIII: Quomodo intelligenda sunt quae de spiritu sancto dicuntur
Caput XIX: De effectibus attributis spiritui sancto in Scripturis respectu totius creaturae
Caput XX: De effectibus attributis spiritui sancto in sacra Scriptura respectu rationalis creaturae, quantum ad ea quae Deus nobis largitur
Caput XXI: De effectibus attributis spiritui sancto secundum quod movet creaturam in Deum
Caput XXII: Solutio rationum supra inductarum contra divinitatem spiritus sancti
Caput XXIII: Quod spiritus sanctus procedat a filio
Caput XXIV: Rationes ostendere volentium quod spiritus sanctus non procedat a filio, et solutio ipsarum
Caput XXV: Quod non sunt nisi tres personae in divinis pater, filius et spiritus sanctus
Caput XXVI: De incarnatione verbi secundum traditionem sacrae Scripturae
Caput XXVII: De errore Photini circa incarnationem
Caput XXVIII: De errore Manichaeorum circa incarnationem
Caput XXIX: De errore Valentini circa incarnationem
Caput XXX: De errore Apollinaris circa corpus Christi
Caput XXXI: De errore Arii et Apollinaris circa animam Christi
Caput XXXII: De errore Apollinaris dicentis animam rationalem non fuisse in Christo, et de errore Origenis dicentis animam Christi ante mundum fuisse creatam
Caput XXXIII: De errore Theodori Mopsuesteni et Nestorii circa unionem verbi ad hominem
Caput XXXIV: Contra errorem Eutychetis
Caput XXXV: De errore Macarii Antiocheni ponentis unam tantum voluntatem in Christo
Caput XXXVI: Contra eos qui dixerunt ex anima et corpore non esse aliquid unum constitutum in Christo
Caput XXXVII: Contra eos qui ponunt duo supposita vel duas hypostases in una persona Christi
Caput XXXVIII: Quid Catholica fides sentiat de incarnatione Christi
Caput XXXIX: Obiectiones contra fidem incarnationis
Caput XL: Quomodo oporteat intelligere incarnationem filii Dei
Caput XLI: Quod assumptio humanae naturae maxime competebat verbo Dei
Caput XLII: Quod humana natura assumpta a verbo non praeextitit assumptioni, sed in ipsa conceptione fuit assumpta
Caput XLIII: Quod natura assumpta a verbo in ipsa conceptione fuit perfecta quantum ad animam et corpus
Caput XLIV: Quod Christum decuit nasci ex virgine
Caput XLV: Quod Christus natus est de spiritu sancto
Caput XLVI: Quod Christus non fuit filius spiritus sancti secundum carnem
Caput XLVII: Quod non sit dicendum Christum esse creaturam
Caput XLVIII: Solutio rationum contra incarnationem superius positarum
Caput XLIX: Quod peccatum originale traducatur a primo parente in posteros
Caput L: Obiectiones contra peccatum originale
Caput LI: Solutio obiectionum positarum
Caput LII: Rationes quibus videtur probari quod non fuit conveniens Deum incarnari
Caput LIII: Quod conveniens fuit Deum incarnari
Caput LIV: Solutio rationum supra positarum contra convenientiam incarnationis
Caput LV: De necessitate sacramentorum
Caput LVI: De distinctione sacramentorum veteris et novae legis
Caput LVII: De numero sacramentorum novae legis
Caput LVIII: De Baptismo
Caput LIX: De confirmatione
Caput LX: De Eucharistia
Caput LXI: De errore infidelium circa sacramentum Eucharistiae
Caput LXII: Solutio praemissarum difficultatum, et primo quoad conversionem panis in corpus Christi
Caput LXIII: Solutio eorum quae obiiciebantur ex parte loci
Caput LXIV: Solutio eorum quae obiiciebantur ex parte accidentium
Caput LXV: Solutio eorum quae obiiciebantur ex parte actionis et passionis
Caput LXVI: Solutio eorum quae obiiciebantur ex parte fractionis
Caput LXVII: Solutio auctoritatis inductae
In the last place, St. Thomas answers the authority from which the heretics took the occasion of attacking the truth of this sacrament1. And he says that from what has been said it is evident that what ecclesiastical tradition holds concerning the sacrament of the Altar contains nothing impossible to God, who can do all things.
Nor is it even against the tradition of the Church that the Lord says: The words that I have spoken are spirit and life. Because the meaning is not that His true flesh would not be delivered to the faithful to be eaten in this sacrament, but because it is received in a certain spiritual manner, beyond the custom of other carnal foods; and not carnally, as though to be torn apart in its proper appearance.
It should be noted that, according to the interpretation of these words set down here, the meaning is: The words that I have spoken to you about eating my flesh have a spiritual sense; because, namely, they are understood not as meaning that my flesh is to be eaten carnally, after the manner of other foods that are torn with the teeth, but that it is to be received in a spiritual manner. And understood in this way, they are life, that is, they bestow life.
St. Thomas also adds another sense, on John2, according to the mind of Augustine, namely: — The words that I have spoken to you are to be referred to the Spirit joined to the flesh. Because, namely, the flesh of Christ, considered in itself, insofar as it is flesh, profits nothing; for it has no other effect than other flesh. But joined to the Word and to the Holy Spirit, it profits much, and bestows eternal life. And understood in this way, they are the life of the soul, that is, that which is expressed through them is the life of the soul, because the soul lives by a spiritual life through the Holy Spirit and the divinity.