On the Spirit and the Letter; An Epistle to Marcellinus
Augustine of Hippo (354–430)
De Spiritu et Littera
First published 412
Written for Marcellinus around 412, this treatise examines the relation of divine law, human freedom and grace, with particular attention to the Apostle Paul’s words that the letter kills but the Spirit gives life.
Caput I: The Occasion for writing this book. That something may be capable of happening, though it has never happened.
Caput II: That the error of those who claim that a person can live presently without sin is less dangerous than the error of those who deny the necessity of grace, which is more serious and must be vigorously refuted.
Caput III: True grace is a gift of the Holy Spirit, by which delight in and love of the good is wrought in the soul.
Caput IV: The teaching of the Law, without the life-giving Spirit, is the letter that kills.
Caput V: What is there to discuss?
Caput VI: The Abundance of Transgression through the Law
Caput VII: The Source from which Good Works flow.
Caput VIII: The Observance of the Law; the nature of the Jew's boasting. Fear of Punishment. Circumcision of the Heart. In what sense the Pelagians acknowledge God as the author of our justification.
Caput IX: The Righteousness of God, as manifested through the Law and the Prophets.
Caput X: That the Law is not laid down for the Righteous.
Caput XI: Piety is wisdom. The righteousness of God is that which God makes.
Caput XII: The Knowledge of God through Creatures. Law without Grace.
Caput XIII: The Law of Works and the Law of Faith
Caput XIV: The Decalogue also kills, unless grace is present.
Caput XV: Grace, hidden in the Old Testament, is revealed in the New.
Caput XVI: Why the Holy Spirit is called the Finger of God.
Caput XVII: A Comparison of the Mosaic Law to the New Law
Caput XVIII: The Old Law brings death; the New, righteousness
Caput XIX: The Christian Faith concerning the assistance of Grace. The Prophecy of Jeremiah regarding the New Testament. Law. Grace.
Caput XX: The Old Law. The New Law
Caput XXI: The Law written in the hearts.
Caput XXII: Eternal Reward
Caput XXIII: The reformation currently taking place, as compared with the perfection of Future Life
Caput XXIV: The eternal reward proper to the New Testament, foretold by the prophet. How that all will have this reward. The Apostle as a vigorous defender of grace. The law written upon hearts, and the reward of eternal contemplation, as pertaining to the New Testament. Who are the ‘lesser’ and the ‘greater’ among the blessed?
Caput XXV: The Distance between the Old and New Testaments
Caput XXVI: An inquiry into the passage of the Apostle concerning the Gentiles, who are said to fulfill the law by nature and to have it written in their hearts.
-
We are next to consider in what sense it is that the Apostle says ‘for when the Gentiles who have not the Law, do by nature the things of the Law, they, not having the Law, are a Law unto themselves, which show the work of the Law written in their hearts.’ For this passage might seem to imply that no clear distinction exists in the New Covenant in the Divine promise to write His Laws in the hearts of His people, inasmuch as the Gentiles possess these Laws by nature. This question therefore has to be discussed; and it is by no means insignificant. For someone will say, if God distinguishes the New Covenant from the old precisely because in the Old He wrote His Law on tables, but in the New has written them in the heart: how are the faithful of the New Covenant to be distinguished from the Gentiles, who have the work of the Law written in their hearts, so that they do by nature the things of the Law; as if they were superior to that ancient people who received the Law written on tables, and in advance of the new nation upon which the New Covenant has conferred what these Gentiles already possess by nature?
-
Is it possible that the nations whom the Apostle mentioned as having the Law written in their hearts were those who belong to the New Covenant? We must look to the context from which it is derived. In the first place, commending the Gospel he says for it is the power of God to salvation to everyone that believeth, to the Jew first and also to the Greek. For in it the righteousness of God is revealed from faith to faith, as it is written, the righteous lives by faith.’ Then he goes on to speak of the ungodly whose knowledge of God did not profit them, owing to their pride, because they did not glorify Him as God, nor give Him thanks. Thence he passes on to those who judge other people and do the same things which they condemn (meaning unquestionably the Jews, who gloried concerning the Law of God, although he has not so far mentioned them by name), and so he says, ‘Indignation and wrath, tribulation and anguish, upon every soul of man that worketh evil, of the Jew first and of the Greek: but glory and honour and peace to every man that worketh good, to the Jew first and to the Greek. For there is no acceptance of persons with God. For whosoever have sinned without Law shall also perish without Law. And whosoever have sinned in the Law shall be judged by the Law. For not the hearers of the Law are righteous before God, but the doers of the Law shall be justified.’ To this passage he adds the words under discussion: ‘for when the Gentiles who have no Law do by nature the things contained in the Law,’ and the rest which I have already quoted. Evidently therefore no others seem to be represented under the title ‘Gentiles’ than those whom he had previously represented as Greeks, when he said, ‘To the Jew first and to the Greek.’ Further, if the Gospel is ‘the power of God to salvation to every one who believes, to the Jew first and to the Greek; and wrath and indignation, tribulation and anguish upon every soul of man that worketh evil, of the Jew first and also of the Greek; but glory and honour and peace to every man that worketh good, to the Jew first and to the Greek;’ and if this ‘Greek’ represents the Gentiles, doing by nature the things of the Law, and the work of the Law which they have written in their hearts: then clearly the Gentiles who have the Law written in their hearts belong to the Gospel, which to those who believe is the power of God unto salvation. But to what Gentiles working aright could there be promised glory and honour and peace, if they are placed beyond the grace of the Gospel? For since there is no acceptance of persons with God, and it is not the hearers of the Law but the doers who are justified; it follows that whether a man is a Jew or a Greek, that is, any Gentile who believes, he shall in either case have salvation in the Gospel. For as he afterwards says ‘There is no difference. For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, being justified freely by His grace.’ Or how can it be said that the Greek doer of the Law is justified without the grace of the Saviour?
-
Nor does the Apostle contradict himself in saying that ‘the doers of the Law shall be justified; ' as if men were justified by their works and not by grace: since he says that a man is freely justified by faith without the works of the Law; and by saying ‘freely,’ he desires nothing else to be implied but that works do not precede justification. Indeed he openly says elsewhere, ‘if it is of grace, then it is no longer of works; otherwise grace is no more grace.' But the sentence, ‘the doers of the Law shall be justified' is to be understood as meaning that they are not otherwise doers of the Law unless they are justified: so that justification is not a supplement to works but precedes them. For what else is meant by ‘justified’ than made righteous, that is, by Him who justifies the ungodly, and out of an ungodly person makes a righteous one? For just in ordinary converse if we say that men shall be made free, it is understood to mean that freedom is to be given to those who are already men: but if we say, men shall be created, it is not understood that persons were created who were men already, but that in the act of their creation they are made men. Similarly, if it is said, that the doers of the Law shall be honoured, it is not correctly understood except as meaning that honour comes to those who are already doers of the Law: but when it is said ‘the doers of the Law shall be justified ’, what else is said than that the righteous shall be justified? For the doers of the Law are already righteous. Accordingly it is equivalent to saying, doers of the Law shall be created, not as already existing, but to give them existence: so may the Jewish hearers of the Law understand that they need the grace of the Justifier in order to become doers; or the words ‘they will be justified’ may mean, they will be considered righteous, reckoned righteous, just as it is said of a certain man, ‘but he wishing to justify himself,’ that is to be considered or reckoned righteous. In the same way we say in one sense, God sanctifies His saints, and in another sense, sanctified be Thy name. For the former means that He makes them holy who were not holy, but the latter that what is always holy in itself should be regarded as holy also by men: that is, that it may be reverently feared.
-
If then the Apostle is referring to the Gentiles doing by nature the things of the Law, and having the work of the Law written in their hearts, and desires us to understand it of believers in Christ (since they do not come to faith like the Jews, through a Law already sent them): there is no reason why we should try to distinguish them from those to whom our Lord, promising by the Prophet the New Covenant, says that He will write His Laws in their hearts. For the Gentiles too, by the in-grafting which the Apostle says was granted to the wild olive, belong to the same olive tree, that is to the same people of God. Indeed this Apostle's witness too rather agrees with that of the Prophet, that to belong to the New Covenant is to have the Law of God written not on tables but in the heart: that is to say, to embrace the righteousness of the Law with our innermost affections, where faith works by love. ‘For God justifies the Gentiles by faith; ' which ‘the Scripture, foreseeing, foretold to Abraham saying, in thy seed shall all the Gentiles be blessed’: that by this grace of promise the wild olive should be grafted into the olive, and the faithful Gentiles should be made sons of Abraham in the seed of Abraham, which is Christ; following the faith of him who not having received the Law in tables, and not yet having circumcision itself, ‘believed in God and it was reckoned to him for righteousness.’ And so what the Apostle has said of the Gentiles under these conditions, ‘they have the work of the Law written in their hearts,’ means the same as his words to the Corinthians, ‘not on tables of stone, but on fleshy tables of the heart.’ For so they are made of the house of Israel when their uncircumcision is reckoned for circumcision, showing that the righteousness of the Law does not consist in the cutting of the flesh, but in the love of the heart: since ‘if uncircumcision keep the righteousness of the Law, shall not his uncircumcision be reckoned for circumcision?’ And therefore they are sharers in the New Covenant, in the house of the Israel indeed in which there is no guile, for God places His Laws in their minds and writes them in their hearts by His finger, the Holy Spirit, by Whom is there shed abroad the love which is the fulfilling of the Law.