On the Spirit and the Letter; An Epistle to Marcellinus
Augustine of Hippo (354–430)
De Spiritu et Littera
First published 412
Written for Marcellinus around 412, this treatise examines the relation of divine law, human freedom and grace, with particular attention to the Apostle Paul’s words that the letter kills but the Spirit gives life.
Caput I: The Occasion for writing this book. That something may be capable of happening, though it has never happened.
Caput II: That the error of those who claim that a person can live presently without sin is less dangerous than the error of those who deny the necessity of grace, which is more serious and must be vigorously refuted.
Caput III: True grace is a gift of the Holy Spirit, by which delight in and love of the good is wrought in the soul.
Caput IV: The teaching of the Law, without the life-giving Spirit, is the letter that kills.
Caput V: What is there to discuss?
Caput VI: The Abundance of Transgression through the Law
Caput VII: The Source from which Good Works flow.
Caput VIII: The Observance of the Law; the nature of the Jew's boasting. Fear of Punishment. Circumcision of the Heart. In what sense the Pelagians acknowledge God as the author of our justification.
Caput IX: The Righteousness of God, as manifested through the Law and the Prophets.
Caput X: That the Law is not laid down for the Righteous.
-
Now ‘Law is not designed for a righteous person,’ ‘but it is good if a man use it lawfully.' When the Apostle associates these two apparent contraries, he warns and urges the reader to investigate the problem and to solve it. For how is ‘the Law good if a man use it lawfully,’ if the following statement is also true, ‘knowing this, that Law is not made for a righteous man’? For who does use the Law lawfully except a righteous man? Yet it is not made for him but for the unrighteous. Or is the unrighteous man to use the Law lawfully in order that he may be justified, since it is as a teacher leading him to grace, through which alone it is possible to fulfil what the Law commands? Through it he is justified freely, that is without any previous merits in his own actions, ‘otherwise grace would not be grace.' For grace is given, not because we have done good works, but in order that we may be able to do them: that is, not because we have fulfilled the Law, but in order that we may be able to fulfil it. For He Himself has said, 'I came not to destroy the Law but to fulfil it': He of whom it is said 'We beheld His glory, glory as of the only-begotten of the Father, full of grace and truth.’ This is the glory of which it is said ‘all have sinned and fallen short of the glory of God.’ And this is the grace of which he goes on to say ‘being justified freely by His grace.’ The unrighteous person therefore uses the Law lawfully in order that he may become righteous; and when that is achieved let him no longer use the Law as a means of arrival when he has arrived, or rather, to adopt the Apostle's previously quoted illustration, as a teacher when he has become learned himself. But how is it that the Law is not made for a righteous man, if for a righteous man also it is necessary, not to lead one who is unrighteous to justifying grace, but to be used lawfully by one who is already righteous. Or is it perhaps the case (Nay, not perhaps but assuredly) that the man who is already righteous lawfully uses the Law when he applies it as a menace to the unrighteous; in order that when the disease of unwonted desire begins to be intensified in them by the provocation of being a thing forbidden, and, by the cumulative effect of their previous transgressions, they should flee by faith to justifying grace, and becoming delighted with the sweetness of righteousness, through the gift of the Spirit, they may escape the penalty of the letter which threatens them. Thus these two Apostolic statements that even a righteous man uses the Law lawfully, and yet Law is not made for a righteous man—are not contraries nor opposed to one another. For he is not justified by it, but by the Law of faith, whereby he believed that it was impossible for him in any way to fulfil through his own weakness what the law of works commands, unless he were supported by the grace of God.
-
Accordingly he says ‘Where then is your glorying? It is shut out. By what Law? Of works? No, but of the law of faith.' He may be using the term glorying in the sense of something to be commended, namely, that which is in the Law, and says that it is excluded, not in the sense of being driven away, but in the sense of being forced out into prominence. This is the sense in which certain silver smiths are called excluders (or pressers out). Thus it says in the Psalms 'That they may be excluded who are tried by silver:' that is, that they may become prominent who are tried by the Word of the Lord. For elsewhere also it is said: ‘The words of the Lord are pure words, silver tried by fire.' Or the Apostle may desire to refer to a sinful glorying, born of pride, the conduct of those who, when they appear to themselves to live righteously, glory as if it were not due to a gift received. And glorying of this sort the Apostle says is excluded (that is, cast out and thrown away) not by the law of works, but by the law of faith. For by the law of faith every man perceives that if he lives at all a life which is good, he owes it to the grace of God, and that, if he is to be perfected in the love of righteousness, he can acquire it from no other source.