Palladium theologicum, Tomus quintus: De virtutibus

Gaudenzio da Brescia

Palladium theologicum, Tomus quintus: De virtutibus

Gaudenzio da Brescia (1612–1672)

Reuerendi patris Gaudentij Bontempi, ... Palladium theologicum, seu Tota theologia scholastica in septem tomos distributa. Ad intimam mentem d. Bonauenturae seraphici doctoris ... Tomus quintus, De virtutibus

First published 1676

Bontempi's Palladium theologicum (Lyon 1676) is a complete scholastic theology composed ad mentem D. Bonaventurae, arranged in seven tractatus on the order of the Secunda secundae. This fifth volume, De virtutibus, treats the theological virtues (faith, hope, charity, with their gifts, beatitudes and fruits), the cardinal virtues and their opposite vices, and the states and offices of men (religious and prelates, bishops, princes), including the extensive disputations on contracts, religion, vows, fortitude, temperance and the judicial process. It is a significant example of the Bonaventurian scholastic school and a counterpart to the Thomist manuals of the period.


Tractatus I: ON THE THEOLOGICAL VIRTUES

Tractatus II: ON CONTRACTS

Tractatus III: ON RELIGION

Tractatus IV: ON VOWS

Proemium I: Prooemium

Disputatio I: FIRST. ON THE VOW

Disputatio II: SECOND. ON THE STATE OF RELIGION, OR ON SOLEMN VOWS

Disputatio III: On the Vow of OBEDIENCE

Disputatio IV: On the Vow of Poverty

Disputatio V: On the Vow of CHASTITY

Quaestio I: What difference there is between Cloistered, and Clerical, chastity

Quaestio II: From what time the solemn vow of Chastity began to dissolve a subsequent marriage

Quaestio III: Whether one vowing Chastity solemnly dissolves a marriage, whether consummated, or ratified, and by what law, and at what time this began to be done

Quaestio IV: By what law, and at what time, Religious Chastity began to be sealed with cloister

Quaestio V: By what means cloister is violated

Subquaestio I: By what modes a Religious going out violates the Cloister

I suppose first that the obligation is grave in those who live a cenobitic life under the government of some Prelate, that they do not go out without his license; it is evident from the common practice and custom of all religions; and it is moreover confirmed from the Council of Tridentino, sess. 25, cap. 4, where it is thus had: It is not licit for Regulars to depart from their convents, even under pretext of approaching their Superiors, unless they have been sent or called by them. Hence Suarez says, loco citato supra, that, supposing the institution of this custom and of the Religious life, this obligation of not withdrawing oneself from the custody of the Prelate is not merely positive, but seems natural and divine, even if no depraved intention, or apostasy, or occasion of other danger should arise from it; and he exemplifies in a girl, who by a law more than positive is held, even with danger set aside, not to withdraw herself from the custody of her father or mother; and he concludes that Religious Chastity and its decency are not to be kept less. Besides, as S. Bonavent. says, lib. II. Pharet. cap. 32, from D. Bernardo: Nothing is more shameful than a Monk running about through cities and castles, unless charity compels this.

Hence the determination of Navarrus does not please me, which also displeases Suarez, by whom it is cited in the place cited, that an exit from the cloister has in its nature only a venial fault, and becomes mortal only per accidens by reason of scandal or other similar harm; for the Council of Tridentinum speaks under precept: It is not licit, and although it is specified there: Even under pretext of approaching their Superiors, that particle even (etiam) a fortiori denotes that other modes or pretexts of going out are less licit.

I suppose secondly that in this matter levity of matter can exist, by which the exit of a Religious without the license of the Prelate is reduced to a venial fault, as if it be done for a short time with the mind of soon returning; and this is true a potiori when it is established from the benignity of the Superior, who easily grants pardon, or if he is accustomed to know of the unlicensed exit and not disapprove: Suarez brings the reason of this thing, num. 10, because the withdrawal from the will of the Prelate is not grave; these things being supposed.

I assert that a Religious cannot go out of the Monastery publicly or furtively, for flight or apostasy, without mortal fault.

It is evident in itself, for there the grave observance is broken, and grave injury is inflicted on the Prelate; just as enormous scandal also threatens the others; wherefore among the cases reserved to the Supreme Pontiff by Clem. VIII, the third is placed: Nocturnal and furtive exit from the Monastery, even if done without the intention of apostatizing; but where there is a reserved case, there the commission of a mortal fault is supposed. But Suarez extends this case, num. 7, even to a diurnal exit, done with the intention of passing the night abroad; because in that decree of the Pontiff not the furtive mode of exiting, but the reason of existing outside furtively is reserved.

Hence you have that a Religious going out without license, on some hasty occasion of succoring a neighbor suffering grave spiritual or temporal necessity, does not sin, because in this case license is rightly presumed; although it ought to be asked, if time permits, at least if it be necessary to go farther away and be absent, because then scandal may impend over the other brothers.

In these cases, however, the custom of each Religion must be weighed: For among the Fratres Minores, on account of the frequent necessity of begging, as also of serving one's neighbor, enclosure is not observed so strictly; indeed often some, destined to such offices, go out at their pleasure, a general license for this having been given.

But a stricter reason must be had of Carthusians, Camaldulenses, and similar ones, serving only God and themselves: For with these one must stand by the rules and constitutions.

By what modes the enclosure of Religious is violated by the entrance of outsiders.

Then D. Bonavent. says, lib. 4. Pharet. cap. 18: Good honor is in the Church, if women are far from the company of Clerics, as D. Hieronymus admonishes in the S. Doctor there: Let the feet of women tread your little hostelry rarely, or never. But before the Pontificates of Pius V and Gregory XIII, various women of various even states could enter the cloisters of men, either by force of the faculties of prior Pontiffs, or by virtue of the Constitutions of certain Convents: But since from this occasions of scandals easily arose, the aforesaid Pontiffs issued their own Motus proprii (since in the law nothing express exists on this matter), by which entrance is interdicted to all women presuming under pretext of whatever faculty, under penalty of excommunication latae and reservatae, that they no longer attempt to enter the Houses of the Mendicants, or of the Carthusians, or of other whatever Regulars by force of any faculty: The Motus of Pius V is had in Bullario Roman. Constit. 22, and begins: Regularium personarum, in the year 1566, in which moreover the local Prelates are strictly prohibited, under the penalties of suspension from Divinis, privation of offices, and incapacity for them, that they do not receive the said women: But the Motus more properly of Gregory XIII is had in Constitut. 36, beginning: Ubi gratis.

But a grave doubt arose after those decrees were issued, whether also women entering the Monasteries of men, not by force of any faculty, would incur the censures; since Gregory XIII says, Inhibiting the same to those who obtained them. With which words Pius V issued other not dissimilar ones: Prohibiting the women pretending the aforesaid faculties and licenses, etc. On account of which words Suarez judged that the censuras regard only the women there noted, not others: But this Doubt was threshed out by another Decree, issued by the same Pius V, where he declares that he comprehends under the censuras the said women and all others whatever; which, when Suarez had seen this, he sang the palinode of the prior opinion, as P. Elizeus noster notes in methodo rerum Criminal., tract. 10, quaest. 23, where he teaches that the Decree begins, Decet Romanum.

Hence the assertion is certain, that a Prelate, and a fortiori any other Religious, sins by introducing into interior houses, or into the cloisters themselves, women comprehended in the said Decrees. It is evident from the penalties there indicted; which suppose a grave sin, and from the Council of Trident. granting the faculty of absolving from those censuras when they are occult, sess. 24, de reform., cap. 6. Therefore it supposes sin through the censuras.

Although in the aforesaid motus proprii women are specified of whatever status, grade, order, condition, and endowed with whatever dignity and pre-eminence, whether they be Comitissae, Marchionissae, or Ducissae; nevertheless it is not gathered from that that it is prohibited to admit Queens, and their daughters, or granddaughters, or even Foundresses of Coenobia. And this is true to such an extent, although Gregory XIII says, To whatever even Comitissae, Marchionissae, Ducissae, and others of whatever status, where the particle others (aliis) is ridiculously interpreted by descending, but is rightly understood by ascending to the higher grades, according to the rigor of the law, as Suarez aduerts, lib. 1, tract. 9, de Relig., cap. 7, num. 5. For since both Pontiffs speak in nearly the same mode, it is a sign that the intention of each is equal as to the specification of persons: But from Pius V it is in no way gathered that he comprehended foundresses, much less Queens, or their daughters, or granddaughters; since there he named the special persons whom he intended to be understood. Besides, Gregory XIII, below, treating the matter which pertained to Kings and Queens, names them. Moreover, the rule of law is, that in a general clause those things are not comprehended which require a special reason, especially when others of inferior note are specified in the same clause.

But that Queens and Foundresses have a special cause is evident first of all from the custom, which custom seeks out these Monasteries.

Then, Suarez verifies, according to the mind of the moderns, that after the Religious of the Order of Minimorum had consulted the Supreme Pontiff and the S. Congregation of Cardinals whether the aforesaid Decrees would exclude Queens and foundresses, they received the answer that no derogation had been made from the privileges which Queens and foundresses enjoyed.

Reason also favors these privileges as regards foundresses (for as regards Queens it is nowhere disputed). For since they are in a certain manner the Dominae and Patronae of the Monasteries which they themselves built, and since the Ius patronatus enjoys privileges in many places in law, it was becoming that they not be involved in the same prohibition as other women: But this presses more among the Minores, since the places constructed for them are under the Dominion of those who took care that they be constructed, unless by special mention such dominion be abdicated, and thus pass into things whose property pertains to the Pontiff; but the use alone pertains to the Brothers themselves.

And although the Monasteries be in the dominion of those Brothers who can truly possess them in common, nevertheless laws are not to be so interpreted as to wish benefactors to be withdrawn from benefacting, or the Brothers themselves to incur so great a note of ingratitude.

Hence one may conclude that women entering, with fraud, malice, presumption, or temerity set aside, do not violate the law of enclosure; because the Pontiff in the said Decrees uses the particle presuming (praesumentes), so that if they enter even from culpable ignorance, they are not judged to sin, and therefore to undergo no censure, as Pater Elizaeus notes excellently in the place cited, numero 2; a fortiori, say the same, if they enter on account of the infirmity of some Religious whom they can succor, or for Masses, sermons, and similar things: they are held, however, to go and return by the straight way, as the cited Elizaeus has, saying that even an ingested boy not pubescent does not violate this law, since in them the end of the law ceases, and the occasion of impudicity, against which these things are statutes.

But by CONSUETUDINE it is received that, the cloisters being destroyed, or lying open through grave fracture, that rigor is not observed; although it is advisable that, with the greater diligence that can be done, every access be precluded to seculars on account of the decency of the Religious state. Which decency also can oblige Prelates, that they do not admit even men into the interior houses at fixed times; although no special precept is given about this.

How the enclosure of Nuns is violated by exit.

I SUPPOSE the rigid precept given to Nuns, that once professed they contain themselves within the cloister, as was proved in quaest. 4, both from the ancient Constitutions of the Church and from the Council of Tridentino, which thus precepts: But let it be licit for no one of the Sanctimoniales after profession to go out of the Monastery, even for a brief time, under whatever pretext, except for some legitimate cause to be approved by the Bishop, any indults and privileges notwithstanding. Hence you have that only Nuns who have emitted the three vows are comprehended in this decree, not Tertiaries, or even Novices, as Suarez shows at length above; although regarding Tertiary Nuns there must be observed the Constitutio of Pius V, beginning: Circa pastoralis officii, namely that they be admonished by Prelates to emit the essential vows of Religion, and thereupon to observe enclosure; but if they should refuse to render this, let them be interdicted from admitting any more into their Congregation.

You HAVE also that Convers Sisters, duly professed, are included by that decree; since they are truly Nuns, differing from the others only as to certain servile ministries and the want of the Veil.

Yet Pius V, by the said Constitution, limited certain things around these, namely that in places where the other Nuns have need of being sustained by the alms of the faithful, certain ones from the conversae be deputed to collect those alms, and therefore may go out and dwell in a certain contiguous house, four conditions being kept. The first is, that they be at least in their fortieth year. The second, that the place in which they dwell be very near to the other nuns. The third, that they do not enter the Cloister of the Nuns (whom they are accustomed to call Choriste by difference from the Conversae) except in the cases named in that constitution. The last is, that they do not go out of their domiciles except with the license of the Superiors.

But if the religious women cannot be sustained otherwise than by the collection of alms, this faculty of going out ceases: wherefore Gregory XIII in his Constitution, beginning: Deo sacris, enjoins upon the Bishops or Ordinaries that they provide: for as S. Bonavent. relates, lib. 1, phar., cap. 37, from D. Cypriano: She is not to be counted a Virgin of Christ who so lives and goes about that she can be loved by men.

From these you have it concluded that a Nun going out against the tenor of the Decree of Tridentino and the limitations of Pius V sins most gravely; and that this is true also of the militant Orders, as P. Elizzus notes, tract. 10, de poenis et delictis, cap. 23, and Rodriguez, tom. 1, quaest. 49, art. ult., and Lezana, tom. 1, cap. 25, num. 19; for the Virgin seeking Christ (says D. Bonav., cited below, from D. Ambrosio) ought not to be vulgar, ought not to be in the forum, not in the streets.

But the CAUSES of going out are specified by Pius V in Constitutio 100, Decori, and are reduced to a great fire and infirmity, which is there called Epidemia, under which name Suarez understands not only that sickness which for the most part infects and kills others by its contagion, but any other whatsoever which can be a scandal or danger to the community. Likewise under the name of fire other dangers cognate to this can come, as war impending, a sudden inundation, and similar ones, which are scarcely met otherwise than by exit.

But P. Elizzus noster observes, in the place cited, from Gregory XIII, that a professed woman having gone out with both feet and body beyond the door violates the enclosure, even if it be for a short time; yet Diana excuses such a one, if she has gone out only by two or three palms, as is had in tract. 5, part. 5, resol. 22.

MOREOVER the aforesaid Constitutions are to be observed, according to the doctrine delivered by me in the treatise on laws, tomo 4; for they are not received everywhere, since in several Provinces, from even light causes, the exit of nuns and their dwelling for a long time in the houses of their parents is tolerated by the Ordinaries, I know not by what custom: And it seems iniquitous to the laws that they be more easily borne than cared to be kept, since nevertheless, as D. Bonavent. has in the cited place, it does not befit, is not expedient for, is not incumbent upon a Religious to be implicated in the obligations of his parents, or to be bound by the pernicious familiarity of strangers.

On the entrance into the cloisters of Nuns.

SINCE chastity is endangered not only by the exit of Nuns, but also by the entrance of others to them, therefore both are prohibited with an equal rigor of the laws; whence in the Council of Malisconense I, cap. 2, Arelatense IV, cap. 7, the Seventh Synod, sess. 7, can. 20, and before in the Council of Agathense, cap. 28, it was statutes under various limitations that the Monasteries of Nuns be guarded from the access and speech of men; that they be placed farther from the Monasteries of Monks, and that all be barred from access and entrance, unless paternal or fraternal urgency of kinship. But Bonifacius VIII, cap. unico, de statu regularium, in 6, more universally and strictly bore the precept on this matter, with these words: To no one whatsoever of dishonest person, nor even of honest, unless a reasonable and manifest cause exists, and with the special license of him to whom it pertains, let entrance or access lie open to the same. But since this law at length failed by custom, it is held renewed in the Council of Tridentino, sess. 25, cap. 5, where it is thus said: But let it be licit for no one to enter within the walls of the Monastery, of whatever kind or condition, sex, or age they be. And although the Council at the beginning of the said chapter says: The holy Synod renewing the Constitution of Bonifacii VIII, nevertheless afterwards it shows in what it renews, namely as to exit and entrance; but not as to access, as Suarez notes, loco citato, numero 26, where he also shows that other Constitutions observing a similar mode of speaking renew or intimate nothing about access. Much less are the Minores barred from approaching by force of the rule, since it only says: Let them not enter Monasteries, etc. Nevertheless the counsel of D. Bernardi is most excellent, in the S. Doctore, cap. 38, in the place cited, having regard to the virgin, that she beware of things to be feared, even to dread safe things.

Therefore only the entering within the walls of Nuns is prohibited by the said Decree. But there went out a Decree of the S. Congregat. in the year 1590, prohibiting not only entrance but access for the sake of speaking, to all Regulars, under penalty of privation of offices and of active, and at the same time passive, voice, to be incurred ipso facto; which prohibition is extended even to all Regulars wishing to address any other women whatsoever dwelling within the walls of the monastery: The same very prohibition, obliging under penalty of mortal sin even for a brief time, the sacred Congregation again declared on 11 Maii, in the year 1669, with the approval of the Supreme Pontiff Clemente IX.

Moreover, although the Council says, of whatever age, nevertheless it must not be believed that boys still infants are comprehended there, since they are incapable of precept; but those words seem to be employed on account of others, who by reason of old age or of more advanced age thought no danger impended over themselves or others. But boys, although they have not the liberty of sinning, can nevertheless fall under the end and motive of the law, wherefore those admitting or introducing them are not excused from sin, any more than from the censure, especially if they be of greater age, since by carrying themselves scurrilously and jocosely they can act against due honesty and decency.

But that precept also involved the prelates of the nuns themselves, as also of other Regulars, that they do not enter except under due conditions; wherefore the prelates of nuns entering in an undue mode, even if they flourish in pontifical dignity, are the first time interdicted from the church; for the second they are suspended; for the third truly they are excommunicated: But the prelates of Regulars are deprived of all offices and excommunicated, according to the Bull of Gregory XIII of the year 1581, which begins: Dubiis, quae emergunt; see Lezanam cited, cap. 16, num. 27, with Elizeo cit., num. 5.

Although it is strictly prohibited to the fratres Minores by the rule that they not enter the monasteries of Nuns; nevertheless Leo X conceded to them that, provided they were invited by the visitators of the nuns, they could enter there with the license of their superiors; which privilege P. Elizaeus shows still to prevail, notwithstanding every revocation by the oracle of the living voice, made by Urbano VIII, 2 decembris 1627, because Paulus V, in 1569, and Clemens VIII, in 1597, confirmed with various Bulls the privileges of the Capucins, so that they are no longer reckoned among the oracles of the living voice.

Moreover, in the same place P. Elizaeus reports that the said Urban VIII, before the then General of our order Ioan Maria a Nuto, declared that he had willed to innovate nothing as to the privileges granted to us.

Finally, it must be observed that he or she who, by entering or exiting, should attempt to surmount the claustral walls, although he would sin gravely, nevertheless does not incur the censures until he reaches the place in which he would truly be said to be within the cloister; because only then is that sin held to be consummated: but that place is held to be all the space deputed to enclosure, in which the nuns can freely station themselves, and outside of which they cannot remain without violation of the enclosure. Thus Bonacina, tract. de Clausura, q. 4, with others in common.

Hence you have that, whether a garden (viridarium) or other places even most remote from the coenobium of the nuns, they cannot be approached if they are within the walls of the monastery and deputed to enclosure; I say deputed to enclosure, because if the Monastery is only built, or the common accesses lie open and permit, such places are not held to be deputed to enclosure.

And although the end of the law ceases in a certain mode in women wishing to enter the monasteries of nuns, nevertheless they are not excluded from this law, even if they should wish to enter under religious habit; since it was said: to no one whatsoever of dishonest person, or even of honest, let entrance lie open, and this is extended to the nuns of other orders also, so that they can enter no cloister other than their own. The reason is, because they are externs to such a convent, and against them the same reason militates which excludes the other women; namely that the discipline of each convent be the better conserved without suspicion or scandal among the persons of the same order; wherefore if there be a nun not of another order, that she can licitly enter and be received by the Priorissa or Abbatissa, without any other faculty of the superior, Bonacina judges, loco cit., prop. 2, num. 3.

Quaestio VI: Whether dispensation can fall upon Religious chastity, and who can dispense in cloister

Disputatio VI: On the Oath

Disputatio VII: On Adjuration

Disputatio VIII: On Divine Praises

Disputatio IX: On the Observance of Feast Days

Disputatio X: On Superstition

Disputatio XI: ON THE TEMPTATION OF GOD

Disputatio XII: ON SACRILEGE

Disputatio XIII: ON SIMONY

Disputatio XIV: ON THE OTHER VIRTUES ANNEXED TO JUSTICE

Tractatus V: ON THE VIRTUE OF FORTITUDE

Tractatus VI: ON TEMPERANCE

Tractatus VII: ON THE VARIOUS STATES AND OFFICES OF MEN

↑ Top of work